I'm a Neutrogena fan myself. I tried the Aveeno. It was ok but didn't necessarily clear up or prevent breakouts. Right now I'm using Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Wash (the orange liquid in the pump bottle) and Neutrogena Multi-Vitamin acne treatment and my skin is looking better than it has in years. I'll be 41 next month and have tried just about every over the counter product there is and I always
end up coming back to Neutrogena. You'll have to try for yourself though. We all respond so differently to the same products and what works for one doesn't always work for another. Good luck!