I still stand by Burt's Bees wild lettuce bar, but it's better for people with oily skin. It works just as well as it did months ago when I first started using it.
To anyone using this, I did notice one thing about BB, which might explain some users' claims that the effects wore off. The first half of the bar seems to be more weighted in effective ingredients. When my bar gets down below half its original size, I get a new one and see that it seems to work better again. Just use the last half to wash your hands. They'll get squeaky clean.