Re: Facial sunscreen [no breakouts]
It sounds to me like the titanium dioxide which is the active ingredient in each of those is what is making you break out. Sometimes, its the active ingredient in sunscreens which causes the whiteheads and the clogged pores.
Neutrogena also makes a line called Clear Face which contains all natural ingredients such as Mica and Zinc, neither of which clog pores and both are less irritating. Have you tried that one?
RRMS- dx 05