If you are not a registered member of our community, please click here to register...



 Home Message Boards Health Guide Join for Free Testimonials About Us
Search
   
  


PDA

View Full Version : Are Muffins Healthy?


IOMEGAZZ27
06-13-2004, 02:27 PM
I have just started buying mini banana muffins (6 to a pack/no nuts) from a local bakery. I have 1-2 and low-fat milk for breakfast with juice. I am trying to improve my eating habits. Are muffins good anytime or should I be eating something else for breakfast instead?

Thanks All. :bouncing:

Sponsor
 



girlygirl11
06-13-2004, 03:02 PM
Depeding on the muffin, they can be fairly healthy. Obviouslyother things are healthiER (such as eggs, cottage cheese, granola, etc), but some muffins aren't as mad as, say, donuts. I don't know the specifics of your particular muffins, but if theyre low-fat, then they are good. They will be more caloric with nuts, but nuts are very healthy, so you could look into that. There are also new muffins that are made with soy milk(from certain bakeries/grocery stores) that have protein as well. Obviously the more nutrients, the better. In my opinion, muffins for breakfast arent the worst food to have, but I wouldnt have them every day. Also, you may want to add some fruit to your breakfast just to round it out a bit more.

justme_
06-13-2004, 04:55 PM
Yeah, instead of the juice, eat fresh fruit. Aren't muffins loaded with sugar and refined carbs? Or are they whole-grain muffins?
IOMEGA are you trying to lose weight, or just maintain your health?

modert
06-13-2004, 08:09 PM
I have just started buying mini banana muffins (6 to a pack/no nuts) from a local bakery. I have 1-2 and low-fat milk for breakfast with juice. I am trying to improve my eating habits. Are muffins good anytime or should I be eating something else for breakfast instead? Thanks All. :bouncing:

Iomega, Lets break down the nutritional value of your breakfast... I don't know your exact muffin, but these numbers are approximate (based on an average of several varieties):

1 7 oz muffin + 8 oz of skim milk + 8 oz OJ:
Calories: 855
Protein: 17 grams
Fat: 27 grams
Carbs: 136 grams
Fiber: 3 grams

Your breakfast, if you eat one 7 oz muffin (or perhaps your 2 mini-muffins = 1 normal muffin) is approximately 64% carbs, 28% fat, and 8% protein. This is a bit heavy on the carbs and not enough protein. This will result in slower metabolism and lack of energy - your food will not sustain you as well throughout the day. You may find yourself quite hungry before your next meal, or you may feel tired and unable to focus mid morning.

If you increase your protein and decrease your carbs you will have a more balanced meal. Have 1/2 muffin or in your case, just 1 minimuffin, choose between the milk and the OJ (but not both) and add an egg or some lean meat, or other protein source to your breakfast. You will probably feel better throughout the morning, have more energy, and be less hungry as the day progresses.

Do you want some suggestions?

justme_
06-14-2004, 03:52 AM
855 calories? :eek: you sure you want that big of breakfast?

Jogaholic
06-14-2004, 01:33 PM
It really depends on what's in the muffin..you could ask the bakery what they use to make them if you're that worried. I wouldn't have them every day, as you should try to eat various types of foods for breakfast throughout the weeks. Breakfast is supposed to be the largest meal of the day, especially if you are trying to lose or maintain weight, as if you eat the most calories in the beginning of your day you will burn them off by the end of the day...whereas the calories you eat at night tend to still be in your system when you go to sleep. You could even get the recipe for the muffins from the bakery and re-vamp it to make them healthier at home (ie: using low-fat products or egg whites). Muffins aren't the worst breakfast in the world and hey, they taste really good.

IOMEGAZZ27
06-14-2004, 01:47 PM
Thanks for the responses! Wow, I did not know muffins were that bad! I don't think I will ever eat another one! Yes, I will take any suggestions anyone has because I am trying so hard to change my way of eating from now on. I just want to get rid of my bad eating habits so I can maintain my weight. There is so much information out there and it seems confusing sometimes. I just started exercising last week and plan to keep that up also.

Thanks again!

modert
06-14-2004, 04:01 PM
Thanks for the responses! Wow, I did not know muffins were that bad! I don't think I will ever eat another one! Yes, I will take any suggestions anyone has because I am trying so hard to change my way of eating from now on. I just want to get rid of my bad eating habits so I can maintain my weight. There is so much information out there and it seems confusing sometimes. I just started exercising last week and plan to keep that up also. Thanks again!

Hi Iomega, its great that you are trying to eat a healthier diet. You will feel better and you will likely prevent the onset of common adult diseases.

One of the most important things to consider is eating a balance of carbs, protein, and fat. You will need to tweak the percentages to what feels best for you, but most people do quite well with a diet of 50% carb, 25% fat, and 25% protein.

Another primary goal should be to maintain blood glucose levels throughout the day. This will help you feel good all day and avoid after meal slumps or pre-meal hunger. To maintain these levels you need to spread out your food consumption throughout the day - could be 5 equal meals or 3 meals and 2 substantial snacks about 3 hours apart. Each of these meals/snacks is best if you use the same carb/fat/protein ratios at the meal level. As with your muffin breakfast - you were short on protein and heavy on carbs - this effects your entire day!

I can't tell you how many calories you should eat, but there are some decent tools out there that can help you determine that. (Do a google search on "BMR Calculator"). Don't forget to factor in activity levels, which will increase your caloric needs. Once you know how many calories to eat to maintain your weight you just need to do some simple math.

Reference for daily totals
To determine carb grams: (total calories X .50)/4
To determine protein grams: (total calories X .25)/4
To determine fat grams (total calories X .25)/9

Reference for meal/snack totals
5 equal meals per day:
Per meal = (total carb grams/5) + (total protein grams/5) + (total fat grams/5)
3 meals + 2 snacks per day:
Per meal = (total carb grams/4) + (total protein grams/4) + (total fat grams/4)
Per snack = (total carb grams/8) + (total protein grams/8) + (total fat grams/8)

There are a few other tips that coincide with the above plans - they are more about the content, not the quantity, of the food you consume. Try to hit these targets:

Avoid processed/refined carbs like white bread, sugar, syrup, etc.
25-30 grams of fiber daily
No more than 300 mg of cholesterol daily
No more than 5000 mg of sodium daily (if you have high BP reduce to 2500 mg or even less)
At least 64 oz of water daily

During the first few weeks you may think its a pain to break down the nutritional value of what you are eating, but until you do it you will never learn. Once you learn, you won't need to go through all the work (measuring, weighing, reading labels, etc) - you will just know. Like with the muffin, you had no idea how imbalanced your breakfast was, but once you saw it all spelled out, it became clear as a bell!

You will need to read labels, perhaps get a kitchen scale (doesn't need to be elaborate, just functional). You will be amazed at what you learn in this process, but it is worth it. Avoid purchasing foods that contain no nutritional data (like your bakery muffins) and stick to foods where you know the ingredients. For example, you will rarely find a nutritional label on a baking potato, but you can weigh it to figure it out yourself. Do a google search on "USDA food data" for a great database to look up food values.

To make things easier, you may want to pre-plan a bit - for example create 4 or 5 different breakfast menus that you will enjoy and then you never have to give it another thought.

Some breakfast examples:
1. 1/2 cup LF cottage cheese + 1 apple + 1 slice Oatnut bread (toast) + 1 tbsp butter + 16 oz of water
2. 2 cups cheerios + 1 cup skim milk + 2 eggs ( no butter - use a nonstick pan or eat them hard boiled!) + 16 oz of water
3. 1 packet instant oatmeal + 1 tbsp butter + 1 3oz lean (low sodium, of possible) ham steak + 1 banana + 16 oz of water

This should give you a good start in the right direction. It may sound like work, but its really not - you just need to apply the knowledge and pretty soon you will do it all from memory. Remember, this is a learning process and you have to start somewhere, if you don't you will just always be guessing. And all of these numbers are goals - if you are off a little in either direction it won't matter much.

girlygirl11
06-14-2004, 04:44 PM
2 mini muffins DO NOT equal 7 oz, and the breakfast isnt even close to 855 calories. I've bought the mini muffins before and they are about 100 calories each. Therefore, 2 of them plus a glass of low fat milk equal about 300 calories, which is a healthy intake.

Jdimassimo- although your diet/nutrition advice may be helpfl to some, I really believe that those who currently eat to hunger should continue to do so. If they are maintaining a healthy weight, then what they are doing isn't harming them. Most people have fairly balanced meals/days without thinking about it (there are people on the other hand who eat junky foods, and they obviously dont). Advising someone to get into calorie counting is such is terrible advice for someone who isn't and doesnt want to lose weight. Once you get in calories, you can't just stop counting. Youre trapped forever in making sure you have enough of everything and every amount. Its a tiring, time consuming thing that is completely unnessecary in many accounts. It leads to eating disorders for many people. I know you have diabetes, according to your other posts, and i understand that you must do this, as do many people who want to lose weight. However IOMEGAZZ2 clearly said she just wants to eat healthy. The best advice is to eat according to the food guide, getting in the daily recommended servings of everything. They have these for a reason- they dont involve calorie counting or such and promote healthy eating habits. I do not think it is beneficial to tell people to start getting into the trap of counting calories if it isnt neccesary. You yourself proved how counting calories and making sure everything is absolutely in proportion when you posted about a trip you were going to take, and how you were worried about snacks and such. YOU have to do it, others dont. And others don't understand, nor do they want to- it isn't a fun thing to do (All of this i am saying from personal experience.) I would suggest that you try to not immediately jump to telling people to work out these protein/fat/carb ratios- youve done this repeatedly and I dont feel that the general population is prepared to sacrifice so much. How can you live if youre consumed with portions and this and that IF YOU DONT HAVE TO DO IT??


Furthermore, while many muffins can be unhealthy, anything in moderation is FINE. IOMEGAZZ2, you dont have to ban them from your diet at all- you can have it once/twice a week or so- just follow a food guide and try to get all your servings in!

modert
06-14-2004, 05:34 PM
girlygirl - You can think what you want, but people who come here for advice are asking for a reason. You can give your advice, and I can give mine. I won't tell you what I think of your advice :rolleyes:, so don't be so quick to criticize mine. People will take what they can from these posts... you don't have to read them.

I don't advise people to count calories. Not at all. If that is what you think, you obviously don't comprehend the context of my posts. What I advise is that people BALANCE their consumption of PROTEIN, CARBS, and FATS for healthful eating. You cannot do that effectively without first knowing how many calories you consume. This is not a diabetic concept - this is a basic healthful eating concept. The fact that I have diabetes is irrelevent.

Using the food pyramid is okay, but very difficult for many to follow. Many people want to be more precise than that - exactly what is a "serving?" My advice helps people LEARN how to eat well. Its not hard to follow - it may be most challenging during the first 2-4 weeks. Then, it becomes easy because you have LEARNED. In real life I have helped MANY MANY people using the formulas I post. So don't be so quick to criticize just because it doesn't suit you.

Regarding the muffins, I believe you are wrong. If you look up about 10 different brands of banana muffins they average at about 650 calories for 7 oz. Minimuffins are typically 3-4 oz. Then again, without a scale, you might never know how big those muffins are (which was EXACTLY my point). And even if the calorie level were less, the protein level of the described meal was certainly too low, especially for breakfast.

modert
06-14-2004, 05:59 PM
Thanks for the responses! Wow, I did not know muffins were that bad! I don't think I will ever eat another one! Yes, I will take any suggestions anyone has because I am trying so hard to change my way of eating from now on. I just want to get rid of my bad eating habits so I can maintain my weight. There is so much information out there and it seems confusing sometimes. I just started exercising last week and plan to keep that up also.

Thanks again!

IOMEGA, just want to be sure you don't misunderstand - I don't think I told you NOT to eat the muffins (although someone here is implying that is what I said)... I think my advice was to eat 1/2 of muffin amount that you were eating and add some protein to your meal.

As for my general advice, take what you can from it and apply what you are comfortable with. I think you can really benefit from it - and its NOT as difficult as it may appear at first glance. If you truly want to make improvements to your diet, you really need to go through the excercise of learning what amounts and ratios are right for you. It will be truly enlightening! Let me know if you have any questions.

Nikos
06-14-2004, 07:40 PM
Hey JDIMASSIMO,

Is Cream of Wheat a bad thing to have for breakfast or as a mid-day snack? I want to include that into my breakfast/snack habits at times (to drink with water) – is “COW” an OK meal to have as far as trying to lose weight and help the heart/cholesterol levels a bit?

Thanks

modert
06-15-2004, 12:31 AM
Hey JDIMASSIMO,

Is Cream of Wheat a bad thing to have for breakfast or as a mid-day snack? I want to include that into my breakfast/snack habits at times (to drink with water) – is “COW” an OK meal to have as far as trying to lose weight and help the heart/cholesterol levels a bit?

Thanks

COW is not bad at all, but really should be part of a meal or snack, not the whole meal or snack. You need to add some protein to the mix. For breakfast add some eggs or lean meat and some whole fruit. As a snack also eat some soy nuts, yogurt, or cheese. You want to avoid meals and snacks that are 80-90% carb.

An alternative to COW would be instant oatmeal... has a bit more fiber and protein. If you have 2 packets of COW you will get 6 grams of protein and 2 grams of fiber. 2 packets of instant oatmeal will provide 9 grams of protein and 6 grams of fiber.

Also - many people load up these cereals with sugar, honey, or syrup... not a great idea - just adds more carbs!

IOMEGAZZ27
06-15-2004, 01:17 AM
Thanks again for everyone advice. I understand I have to figure out what works for me eventually. I have saved a lot of your replies to read over again later off-line. It has all been very helpful to me. I wonder if don't count calories will I gain weight because I may be eating too many calories per day? Even if the foods are healthy? I just want to make sure I understand. If I eat healthy and in small portions then I don't have to count calories?? I think I became a little confused. Is there not a right or wrong way to eat healthy. I just want to make sure I'm starting off the right way.

Thanks all again.

:confused:

Nikos
06-15-2004, 07:49 AM
It seems weird for me to eat egg and english muffin with no cheese or sausage.

Is the susage real bad since it has a lot of saturated fat? To me thats the best part of the breakfest sandwhich (I can do without the cheese).

Would it be real bad to have the sausage patty in general? Should I not even think about having it even once in a while?

Would Egg, Cheese, and Muffin with some fruit be ok?

Thanks!

modert
06-15-2004, 08:36 AM
Thanks again for everyone advice. I understand I have to figure out what works for me eventually. I have saved a lot of your replies to read over again later off-line. It has all been very helpful to me. I wonder if don't count calories will I gain weight because I may be eating too many calories per day? Even if the foods are healthy? I just want to make sure I understand. If I eat healthy and in small portions then I don't have to count calories?? I think I became a little confused. Is there not a right or wrong way to eat healthy. I just want to make sure I'm starting off the right way.

Thanks all again.

:confused:

If you don't have a weight problem, you don't need to count calories. I am suggesting that you be AWARE of how many calories you should be eating for your body. One of the problems with the "food pyramid" (you know - that diagram on the side of boxes) is that it assumes everyone needs to eat the exact same amount of calories... this is not true.

I am also recommending that you go through this learning process so you begin to understand how to balance your protein, carbs, and fat. As I suggested, you need to do a little math at the beginning, but after 2-4 weeks you will KNOW what to do. You will be able to make smart choices on your own. You won't need to measure or count, unless of course, you decide you want to. But if you DONT go through this learning process, you will ALWAYS just be guessing. Many people are suprised by how much food they can eat when they change to a healthier diet... you might find that the amount of food is more volume than you have been eating. You will also be able to avoid hunger because your body is getting what it needs.

Regarding weight gain - I'm not sure how old you are, but the odds are that even if you are normal weight now, as you age you will gain. One of the reasons is that the older you become, the fewer calories you need to eat. Another reason is that all the excess calories you eat will slowly begin to show... its not something that you will necessarily see overnight... but it will show up after a while. Other factors that will contribute to this are the efficiency of your body - load it up with junk food, sugars, and chemicals and it will eventually effect your metabolsim - this can cause weight gain AND onset of middle-age diseases (diabetes, heart disease, etc).

girlygirl11
06-15-2004, 01:37 PM
While I agree with some of what jd says, I dont necessarily agree with it all. I do agree that people should be aware of what they're eating, but I don't think that this necessarily has to involve counting the specific grams of things. While this may work for some, I personally find it time consuming and useless. Bascilly, IOMEGAZZ27, you asked whether you need to count calories in order to make sure you dont gain weight. In a word- no. As long as you are eating when youre hungry and stopping when full, and picking healthy choices, you don't really need to count cals or fat/protein/carbs.

Obviously, peolpe can see what has protein, fat, etc. If you stick with lower fat products, eat a lot of protein-rich foods, and fruits and veggies, and try to limit (you dont have to cut out!!) refined startch and sugars, you should be fine. The best way to tell is to try it

Magpiezoe
06-15-2004, 01:56 PM
Hello, Back to the sausage, cheese, and egg muffin. I agree that you are better off eating the egg muffin without the sausage and cheese. Eggs already have fat in them, so you really don't need to add more fat. One egg is really lower in fat than one serving of lean beef. The sausage is ground up left-overs unless you know your butcher personally and can attest to what is in it. Some butchers will use just fresh ground pork and spices. The meat used in sausage is usually the cheap high fat stuff. The casing is pig intestines. As for the cheese, it's fine if it's low-fat or used in moderation. If you can't eat the egg muffin without anything on it, sauteed onions are great with it....Even a little drop of soy sauce is good on egg sandwiches.

tah4349
06-15-2004, 04:18 PM
The casing is pig intestines.

Intestines are incredibly difficult to work with, hard to store, difficult to find, and not that cheap. Most sausage producers today use a synthetic for casings - either made of collagen, fibrous material, or plastic. You'd have to find an old school producer to find real intestines in use. Mass produced sausage, such as that used in fast food or commercial manufacturering, probably would not use intestine casings.

modert
06-15-2004, 06:01 PM
It's still pretty gross - synthetic cellulose or pig intestines? Which is worse? If you MUST eat sausage, get the loose kind (ground and sold like hamburger) and make it into patties. I just avoid it altogether.

euro18
06-16-2004, 10:39 AM
Irrespective of the amount of calories, how can you start a day with a muffin or sausages on a regular basis? Why not some fruit? or a healthy cereal like All-bran. I feel so sorry for your intestines having to digest all that stuff. Many nutritionists say that breakfast is the most important meal of the day , so why start it by eating calorie-laden, nutrionally-devoid foods? Someone said that if u r not putting on weight, then what you're eating is OK! that's not true - I am thin and I could eat whatever I wanted to and not put on weight, but that doesn't mean I would be healthy - merely that I have a fast metabolism.
Look after your body, and it will look after you.

modert
06-16-2004, 11:12 AM
Euro, you are absolutely right - the quality of food and balance of nutrients is vital. A common mistake that young adults make is assuming that because they don't have a weight problem they are healthy. Good health goes far beyond weight control.

Your suggestion of fruit and high fiber grains is a good one. I stand by what I said earlier though - that most people do not eat enough protein, especially early in the day. Eating a carb-heavy breakfast is not a healthful way to start the day. Then again, Its not smart to eat too much protein either.

It can be challenging to identify sources of protein that are not high in fat. Its not advised to eat eggs, meat, and cheese every morning for breakfast because that would be too high in cholesterol and fat. Most people, however, are less willing to eat alternate low-fat protein sources for breakfast. Examples include cottage cheese, yogurt, soy foods, and beans.

euro18
06-16-2004, 12:30 PM
Eating a carb-heavy breakfast is not a healthful way to start the day. Then again, Its not smart to eat too much protein either.

Yeah I agree. I recently changed my eating habits because I was eating way too many refined carbs such as : cornflakes, pasta, mashed potato. These foods release glucose into your bloodstream way too quickly and a highly refined carb diet has been linked to obesity, diabetes, PCOS, acne amongst other ailments. More protein is a good idea or better still eat foods with a good amount of carbs and protein in them such as almonds or brazil nuts.

modert
06-16-2004, 01:50 PM
My husband had some really bad habits... He would oatmeal, fruit, and a peanutbutter sandwich (a pretty big breakfast) and then go outside and do VERY strenuous yard work. Then he would come inside 2 hours later shaking, practically passed out, having low blood sugar symptoms because he had not eaten enough protein. He could not understand why because in his mind he had eaten protein (peanut butter). I have since converted his ways and he now sees that eating more protein helps sustain his energy and strength.

The fact is that peanut butter is a rather low source of protein and is especially high in fat. Look at the ratios -
Protein:15% Carbs:13% Fat:72%
This is true for most nuts as well - almonds, mixed nuts, etc... Not as healthy a snack as many people believe.

jtu91952
06-16-2004, 03:10 PM
My husband had some really bad habits... He would oatmeal, fruit, and a peanutbutter sandwich (a pretty big breakfast) and then go outside and do VERY strenuous yard work. Then he would come inside 2 hours later shaking, practically passed out, having low blood sugar symptoms because he had not eaten enough protein. He could not understand why because in his mind he had eaten protein (peanut butter). I have since converted his ways and he now sees that eating more protein helps sustain his energy and strength.

The fact is that peanut butter is a rather low source of protein and is especially high in fat. Look at the ratios -
Protein:15% Carbs:13% Fat:72%
This is true for most nuts as well - almonds, mixed nuts, etc... Not as healthy a snack as many people believe.
:wave: :wave: JD i usually learn alot from you on these boards, but I totally disagree about nuts. My dietician suggested i add nuts (walnuts & almonds) to my diet. Sure they're high in fat, but they also have heart healthy nutrients. Not only my dietician suggest this but so does most health professionals. Also she said to much protien is not good for diabetics.Can't too much protien cause liver or kidney problems?

modert
06-16-2004, 03:46 PM
:wave: :wave: JD i usually learn alot from you on these boards, but I totally disagree about nuts. My dietician suggested i add nuts (walnuts & almonds) to my diet. Sure they're high in fat, but they also have heart healthy nutrients. Not only my dietician suggest this but so does most health professionals. Also she said to much protien is not good for diabetics.Can't too much protien cause liver or kidney problems?

Hi JTU, Let me clarify... I don't think nuts are unhealthy. They are a good source of many nutrients. BUT - I don't believe they make as good a snack as some people might think. A few problems with nuts is that they are not that filling, quite easy to overeat, often heavily salted, relatively low in protein, and very high in fat. In fact the high fat content in nuts (peanuts, walnuts, and almonds, etc) is a major contributor to symptoms of heartburn and indigestion in many people. Adding nuts to the diet in moderation is fine, but I don't recommend eating them as a stand-alone snack... Instead of relying on nuts for a snack, sprinkle a few almonds on a salad or over green beans, add a few walnuts to your tuna or chicken, or stirfry a few peanuts in with some veggies and rice with dinner.

Regarding protein - yes, I COMPLETELY agree that consuming protein in excess is not wise (and I don't believe in low-carb plans). But I also believe that if you don't eat enough protein with each meal and snack you compromise the efficiency of your metabolic function. Protein and carbs are best consumed in balanced amounts throughout the day. Following this model, a snack that consists only of nuts would not the best choice. Better to have just a few nuts (say, 1/2 oz) with some cottage cheese or yogurt (balances things out a bit). I personally prefer soy nuts because they are higher in protein and fiber and lower in fat than peanuts, almonds, and walnuts.

euro18
06-16-2004, 06:44 PM
A few problems with nuts is that they are not that filling, quite easy to overeat, often heavily salted, relatively low in protein, and very high in fat. In fact the high fat content in nuts (peanuts, walnuts, and almonds, etc) is a major contributor to symptoms of heartburn and indigestion in many people.

I think nuts are very filling and thus you don't need to eat too many of them so they are hard to over eat. Obviously, it's wise to get unsalted nuts.
They are not relatively low in protein, but provide a good source of protein hence they are included as part of the "meat" group in the food pyramid for this very reason.
According to one doctor, nuts are cholesterol-free and contain mostly mono- and polyunsaturated fats, the so-called good fats, as well as the beneficial omega-3 fatty acid like that found in fish.
Studies looking at almonds, peanuts, pistachio nuts have shown that people who regularly eat these nuts have lower cholesterol levels. Moreover, they are all really good sources of protein and fiber. Almonds are also a good source of vitamin E, magnesium and calcium.

jtu91952
06-16-2004, 07:08 PM
Hi JTU, Let me clarify... I don't think nuts are unhealthy. They are a good source of many nutrients. BUT - I don't believe they make as good a snack as some people might think. A few problems with nuts is that they are not that filling, quite easy to overeat, often heavily salted, relatively low in protein, and very high in fat. In fact the high fat content in nuts (peanuts, walnuts, and almonds, etc) is a major contributor to symptoms of heartburn and indigestion in many people. Adding nuts to the diet in moderation is fine, but I don't recommend eating them as a stand-alone snack... Instead of relying on nuts for a snack, sprinkle a few almonds on a salad or over green beans, add a few walnuts to your tuna or chicken, or stirfry a few peanuts in with some veggies and rice with dinner.

Regarding protein - yes, I COMPLETELY agree that consuming protein in excess is not wise (and I don't believe in low-carb plans). But I also believe that if you don't eat enough protein with each meal and snack you compromise the efficiency of your metabolic function. Protein and carbs are best consumed in balanced amounts throughout the day. Following this model, a snack that consists only of nuts would not the best choice. Better to have just a few nuts (say, 1/2 oz) with some cottage cheese or yogurt (balances things out a bit). I personally prefer soy nuts because they are higher in protein and fiber and lower in fat than peanuts, almonds, and walnuts.
OK i agree with you. That's my problem nuts do not satisfy me (handful) and then i tend to overeat them. So i stop buying nuts. Anything that causes me to overeat I try not to bring into the house. Such as cookies, low fat cheese.

jtu91952
06-16-2004, 07:12 PM
I think nuts are very filling and thus you don't need to eat too many of them so they are hard to over eat. Obviously, it's wise to get unsalted nuts.
They are not relatively low in protein, but provide a good source of protein hence they are included as part of the "meat" group in the food pyramid for this very reason.
According to one doctor, nuts are cholesterol-free and contain mostly mono- and polyunsaturated fats, the so-called good fats, as well as the beneficial omega-3 fatty acid like that found in fish.
Studies looking at almonds, peanuts, pistachio nuts have shown that people who regularly eat these nuts have lower cholesterol levels. Moreover, they are all really good sources of protein and fiber. Almonds are also a good source of vitamin E, magnesium and calcium.

I've heard that almonds and walnuts are especially good for helping lower cholesterol. that's why my dietician told me to add to my diet. I buy plain nuts at Wal Mart or the farmer's market. I agree with JD that nuts are not filling, at least not for me. I usually add them to my salads.

modert
06-16-2004, 10:00 PM
They are not relatively low in protein, but provide a good source of protein hence they are included as part of the "meat" group in the food pyramid for this very reason.

When I say that nuts are "relatively" low in protein I am referring to the ratio of protein to calories. If you are trying to maintain a 50/25/25 ratio or a 40/30/30 ratio, its hard to justify having nuts as a stand-alone snack because it throws the balance completely out of whack. You simply will not get the proper amounts of protein or carbs to stabilize your metabolism.

Sure, nuts have some good fats but fat calories are all equally "fattening" and the fact remains that nuts are 85% fat, 10% protein, and 5% carbs! There are also plenty of alternate sources for the Omega-3s and Omega-6s.

I am not saying don't eat nuts!!! You just need to watch the portions and eat them as part of a snack or meal.

modert
06-16-2004, 10:06 PM
OK i agree with you. That's my problem nuts do not satisfy me (handful) and then i tend to overeat them. So i stop buying nuts. Anything that causes me to overeat I try not to bring into the house. Such as cookies, low fat cheese.

Here is what I do... When I buy nuts or seeds as soon as I get them home from the grocery store I divide the packages into 1/2 oz and 1 oz portions and wrap them in foil packets. This is so helpful when you want to add a portion to salad or to veggie, you just grab a packet and you know exactly how much is in there. Actually I do this with cheese too!

 
 
 




Site owned and operated by HealthBoards.com (TM)
Copyright and Terms of Use © 1998-2008 HealthBoards.com (TM) All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!