I haven't used either of those but I use Oil of Olay Total Effects. I use the regular day lotion and also Total Effects Night Firming Cream. I love both of them. I have tried so many expensive brands and I still think Oil of Olay is better than all of them. It is the only brand that does not break me out. I also use the Daily Facials - Clarifying. It does a light exfoiliation to your face daily without harming your skin. My skin would be a mess without them. They are excellent for removing makeup + cleansing all in one.