Does anyone have any experience with John Sherman, Steven Pearlman, or Nicholas Tabbal, Mark Ehrlich, or Laurence Kirwan?
I have pretty much narrowd down my list and am going to start scheduling consultations soon. I just wanted to know if anyone has positive/negative comments about anyone on my list, because obviously, I'm trying to avoid people with bad reputations for surgical results. I almost went to see Dr. Geofrey Tobias, who I am told is a butcher. thanks in advance.

I had a rhinoplasty with Nicholas Tabbal 3 months ago.He is in my opinion a fine surgeon.However he is very conservative.This is not a problem unless you want something dramatic such as a huge reduction etc.For rhinoplasty he is one of the best.

Hey! I had rhinoplasty with Dr. Aston in NYC yesterday, so I haven't exactly seen the results. However, he has a great reputation and I have a lot of confidence in him. So far, I'm feeling pretty good. Good luck with your rhinoplasty, keep us informed!

I heard Tabbal is really good, I chose to go with Dr. Pastorek I liked him overall the best and he has a great reputation. I am having my surgery on August 6.

Hi,
I am in the NYC area and researched the best plastic surgeons for rhinoplasty, and decided to use Dr. Gerald Acker in Roslyn, NY---he is a truly skilled artist and surgeon. The nose is absolutely beautiful, natural-looking, and perfectly fits my face, and it's been a number of years and I am so happy I used Dr. Acker rather than some of the more "famous" surgeons in NYC. There was absolutely no pain, either.