go with denenberg, trust me. he's excellent. i just got mine done on jan 5 from him, i get my splint off tomorrow morning. he is very professional and i have seen many of his before and after photos, his work is the best of the best. also, i have not heard of ANYONE that said he butchered their nose. he has done over 1,500 rhinoplasties. it is his specialty. he is not cheap but you can not put a price on confidence in your surgeon. if you have to get a secondary rhinoplasty, you're going to be out at least double whatever you pay for your primary.