hi Daisy, your eyes sound like the same color as mine. Shadow colors that will make your eyes POP are a very soft creamy pink or pinkish/lavender tone blends...it will further bring them out to smudge line your eyes with a plum shadow and then feather it out into the outside horizontal V and then feathered back into the crease. Also some shades of grey look great, but it has to be the RIGHT grey and must include a darker grey smudge line process as described above with the plum.