If you are not a registered member of our community, please click here to register...

 Home Message Boards Health Guide Join for Free Testimonials About Us
Search
   
  


PDA

View Full Version : Exercise in the morning. Pointless?


 

 

 
maybebabee
03-16-2006, 07:25 PM
Hey everyone, just a quick question. Due to schedule etc, i have to fit in exercise in the early morning instead of in the middle of the day or late in the evening. I was just wondering if this is less beneficial to weightloss? I know it might seem silly, but it feels less effective as i havent eaten anything at this point, and so seems like i'm not working off any calories? I'm fairly active during the rest of the day just from being on my feet and quite busy, but i dont do a workout or anything from about 9am onwards. Do calories just store up from the day before? Would i be better off working out later in the day? Thanks for any advice xx

Sponsor
 



bluejbirdie
03-16-2006, 07:51 PM
IT is just as good ...If not better......many people believe it is the best time to exercise.

southjerseymom
03-17-2006, 07:29 AM
Any time that fits your schedule is a good time to exercise. Exercising in the early AM will give your metabolism a boost. I see that as beneficial because you'll be burning calories at a higher rate for several hours after your workout.

StenoLady1
03-17-2006, 08:46 AM
Working out in the am versus pm was extremely beneficial for me. My weight barely moved working out in the evenings. When I switched it up to the mornings, the pounds started falling off. Plus I just "felt" better throughout the day when I did it in the mornings.

I'm talking about cardio, tho...not lifting weights. I've heard that should be done later in the day.

HTH

Lenin
03-17-2006, 09:53 AM
maybebabee,

Exercise is great on an empty stomach. Anaerobics can be fueld by the ample glycogen in liver and muscles. Aerobics can be fueled by the bodyfat that we are all trying to lose (the heart likes to run on fat.)

chevyman
03-17-2006, 10:45 AM
I exercise in the mornings before work, and sometimes after work if I get bord,I'll exercise in the evening...like if nothings good on tv or just want something to do..I'll exercise.........I count calories and write them all down, sometimes I start looking at my list I have had that day...and it makes me wanna exercise more...now why I don't know...lol ..maybe its just bordom.
also I've learn that I can not count on the food labels as being correct...some are very mis-leading.
but yeah I would say exercise is more beneficical in the mornings.

OutToLunch
03-17-2006, 11:36 AM
Due to schedule etc, i have to fit in exercise in the early morning instead of in the middle of the day or late in the evening. I was just wondering if this is less beneficial to weightloss? I know it might seem silly, but it feels less effective as i havent eaten anything at this point, and so seems like i'm not working off any calories?

I would say that when it comes to doing cardio for the purpose of losing fat, doing it first thing in the morning is not only NOT pointless, it's actually the ideal time to do it. Both your blood sugar and muscle glycogen will be at their lowest so any moderate intensity cardio you do under these conditions will burn fat. The problem with doing cardio at any other time of the day is that your blood sugar and muscle glycogen won't be low. So any cardio you do will be driven by blood sugar and glycogen. In fact, it's estimated that if you did cardio in the evening like most people do, your body would not start using stored fat until after 20 minutes. I know a lot of people will say it doesn't matter where calories come from just as long as you're burning them and that it all evens out in the end. But let's say those 20 minutes are spent burning off 100 calories that you took in earlier in the day. Wouldn't it have been easier to just not eat those 100 calories in the first place? I value my time and don't really enjoy exercising. So I would like that time to be spent actually burning fat, not just cancelling out food I ate earlier. The fact that afternoon or evening cardio doesn't immediately burn fat is a big reason why I think people don't see significant results and become frustrated. I used to do cardio in the evening and I saw modest fat loss at best. But when I switched to morning cardio, the fat just started melting off. Of course you're going to have more energy in the evening than when you wake up. And that's why the cardio will seem easier. But don't assume that makes the cardio session more effective. Compare 30 minutes of morning cardio with 30 minutes of evening cardio. If you do it in the morning, 30 minutes are spent burning fat. If you do it in the evening, only 10 minutes are spent burning fat. Seems pretty obvious which is better.

There are plenty of other reasons to do morning cardio. First, it jumpstarts your metabolism. And if you eat small, frequent, high protein meals for the rest of the day, you'll keep your metabolism elevated. Second, it'll put you into a healthy mindset for the rest of the day. I've found that on days I do morning cardio, I eat better for the day because I'll look at food and say to myself, "You started the day off right, but if you eat that donut, you'll cancel out that cardio you did this morning." Another advantage is that you get it over with. Too often, people are tired or have other things to do in the evening. Maybe you have to work late or go to your child's soccer game. At least this way, you've gotten in your daily exercise. It's also been shown that people who do morning cardio are better able to concentrate at work. I read an article that interviewed successful CEOs to find out what they had in common. A lot of them said they exercised in the morning and it made them feel more energized during the day.

By the way, if anyone tells you that morning cardio will cause you to lose muscle, don't pay attention to that. Muscle loss is caused by insufficient caloric intake, insufficient protein intake (protein needs are higher for people who exercise), and leaving long gaps between meals. I've been doing morning cardio for months and have only seen a 1 pound loss of muscle.

shucky ducky
03-17-2006, 11:49 AM
Same here. Although exercising at any time is beneficial, I dropped the most weight when I did my cardio in the morning. But I got lazy, didn't want to get up in the mornings, so I started working out in the evening and boy did my weight loss start to slow. After starting my morning workouts again, the weight started to come off again. It definately gets your metabolism going. Another benefit to working out in the morning, if you do it right and at an intense pace, you're going to be hungry afterwards (there's that metabolism racing). It's better to eat a small meal in the morning after your workout than to eat one in the evening. Many people gain weight after they eat and then lie down soon afterwards. Every single overweight person I know eats past 7pm.

MaxOT26
03-17-2006, 01:08 PM
Every single shredded bodybuilder I know, including myself, eat within a hour of bedtime. Personally, I take in close to 500 calories 30 min before I go to bed. Not eating after a certain hour makes no difference. It is the grand total that matters. Feeding your body important nutrients before bed is actually a good stratagy if you are trying to develop a lean physique.

6foot3
03-17-2006, 03:30 PM
I agree with the others that its great in the mornings. My busy work schedual forces me to workout at 4.45 a.m. on an empty stomach with a scoop of protein powder (30 min before) and i do fine........

shucky ducky
03-17-2006, 05:41 PM
Every nutritionist I've ever heard or talked to (including Oprah's) say that if you are trying to lose pounds, you should NEVER eat within 3 hours of going to bed. Every single overweight person I know of all eat too close to their bed time. When I was fighting the battle of the buldge, I would exercise and eat right. I could never figure out why my weight wasn't coming off like it should. Listening to Oprah and her nutrition experts, I stopped eating after 7p and within a week, bam! The weight started dropping off. Everyone's body is not the same. Some people can probably eat before bed time and it won't make a difference in their weight. You're lucky because if I ate 500 calories of any kind before I went to bed, I'd end up with indigestion and I'd be weighing 500 lbs. :)

maybebabee
03-17-2006, 09:29 PM
I would say that when it comes to doing cardio for the purpose of losing fat, doing it first thing in the morning is not only NOT pointless, it's actually the ideal time to do it. Both your blood sugar and muscle glycogen will be at their lowest so any moderate intensity cardio you do under these conditions will burn fat. The problem with doing cardio at any other time of the day is that your blood sugar and muscle glycogen won't be low. So any cardio you do will be driven by blood sugar and glycogen. In fact, it's estimated that if you did cardio in the evening like most people do, your body would not start using stored fat until after 20 minutes. I know a lot of people will say it doesn't matter where calories come from just as long as you're burning them and that it all evens out in the end. But let's say those 20 minutes are spent burning off 100 calories that you took in earlier in the day. Wouldn't it have been easier to just not eat those 100 calories in the first place? I value my time and don't really enjoy exercising. So I would like that time to be spent actually burning fat, not just cancelling out food I ate earlier. The fact that afternoon or evening cardio doesn't immediately burn fat is a big reason why I think people don't see significant results and become frustrated. I used to do cardio in the evening and I saw modest fat loss at best. But when I switched to morning cardio, the fat just started melting off. Of course you're going to have more energy in the evening than when you wake up. And that's why the cardio will seem easier. But don't assume that makes the cardio session more effective. Compare 30 minutes of morning cardio with 30 minutes of evening cardio. If you do it in the morning, 30 minutes are spent burning fat. If you do it in the evening, only 10 minutes are spent burning fat. Seems pretty obvious which is better.

Wow, I wasn't aware of some of that. Thankyou for taking the time to write all of that out, it was really interesting. You're right, if i do the morning exercise and start the day right, it does make me reluctant to fill up on crap later on in the day. I just think of the pain at the gym and how it won't be as worth it if i start eating junk later that same day. It's good to hear so many people saying morning workouts are extremely beneficial and possibly the best time to exercise. It'll definitely come to mind when i'm considering just staying in bed for an extra hour.

Thank you all for your responses, they are much appreciated :)

Paula Puss
03-18-2006, 10:00 AM
i walk about 2 miles every morning. hopefully ill start seeing benefits soon ;)





Site owned and operated by HealthBoards.com (TM)
Copyright and Terms of Use © 1998-2009 HealthBoards.com (TM) All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!