Does smoking make asthma feel better?? - Asthma Message Board

kellie2 · 10-03-2003, 11:19 PM

I was talking to my sister the other day, and she made a comment that turned into a slightly heated discussion between us. She said that she knows people who have asthma (I have it, she does not) who have told her they have more trouble with their asthma and with breathing when they try to quit. She said they've told her they breathe better when they smoke. I told her they may 'think' they're having problems because when you stop smoking you go through withdrawal which can make your chest feel 'funny' and tight, but to say they breathe better when they're smoking doesn't really make much sense if she thinks about it. I mean, come on. Well, after several minutes of going back and forth with her on this, I just changed the subject. Can anyone out there please explain to me what exactly smoking does to an asthmatic's lungs so when it comes up again, I can state facts to support my arguement?

Thanks

QaiphyxXykal · 10-03-2003, 11:36 PM

I would doubt that it makes the asthma better. The tobacco probably calms them and makes them feel better but the asthma is probably just as bad. Tobacco might possibly be a brochial dialator though so who knows.

kjd · 10-04-2003, 09:12 PM

Tobacco smoke temporarily paralyzes the cilia in your lungs, allowing mucus and irritants to build up. When the cilia begin working again, the typical response is to begin coughing the buildup out of your chest, which could simulate and exacerbate asthma symptoms. For many smokers this occurs in the morning upon waking, after 8 or so hours without smoking. Quitting can have a similar effect which naturally lasts longer, as there's no morning cigarette to start the cycle again.

Some people with asthma are able to smoke without short-term difficulty, but I have a hard time believing there is any real benefit to doing so.

Susiek415 · 10-05-2003, 03:27 PM

I found I had more asthma symptoms when I smoked as compared to being smoke free. As my doctor told me if I continued to smoke it would be putting a nail in my coffin. I haven't smoked since...

wrin · 10-05-2003, 09:38 PM

kjd's figured it out.

Smoke is an irritant and will cause bronchoconstriction and will cause inflammation and is not good for your lungs.

But these people might be having trouble quitting smoking, and might be using it as an excuse.

That's their prerogative to quit smoking. Next time your sister gets in an argument about it, tell her to go to the local University and apply for a grant to research it, because you're not arguing until she comes back with the papers recording her findings.