Originally Posted by Moon Rising
I have been using Maybelline Expert eyes velvet black pencil (the red one, and comes in a two pack) for 17 years now!! I love it that much. I melt it with a lighter just for a sec before I put it on (doing that for 17 years too). Then I have black eye shadow that I blend over it with a small eye shadow brush so I dont have d*****ate lines. Works great! Lasts all day. Don't make your lines to wide , and keep it sharpened and you'll never get coon eyes.
My mom has been using the same stuff for as long as I can remember. I even use it too, sometimes. Instead of the lighter I use a quick blast of the hairdryer and it goes on nice and smooth then sets for all-day wear. I didn't realize they made it in black so I instead bought some Prestige eyeliner (which I like), but I will be needing to check that out now.