Don't use Covergirl Aquasmooth.. it is one of my favorite products, but the Ivory is darker than other brands. I use self tanner now, but before using it, Ivory was a little darker than my skin. I know Almay has lighter colors, but I haven't tried them out. I do NOT recommend Loreal Ideal Balance. Since they had a light color and I have combination skin I thought it would be great.. WRONG! It made me break out really bad. I used to get occasional breakouts on my forehead and then I started breaking out a lot on my cheeks and had acne scars for about a year until they finally faded

.
I know Clinique is also kind of dark.. I'd look into Almay.. it looks like they have a lot of good products. I love the cream to powder foundations that are in a compact.. they offer a little bit of coverage without being too thick.