Open vs. closed rhinoplasty - Cosmetic / Plastic Surgery Message Board

Kittystev · 03-31-2004, 12:26 AM

Does anybody know, is there a difference (if doctors' skill is not taken into account), in terms of final results, between open and closed rhinoplasty? I mean does it heal faster or looks better if done with closed? Does closed work better on noses with little improvement needed and open for noses which need a lot of correction? Because there are only two types of surgeons: those performing open rhino and those performing closed rhino (the last say they also perform open rhino, but only on difficult cases, which is almost 5%). I wouldn't say my nose is difficult, but I would say it definitely needs more than a tiny correction

.
So, if anybody noticed a difference in the final outcome between the 2 procedures please let me know, it would be very helpful in making a decision on what type of surgeon should I pick for my rhino.

katty233 · 03-31-2004, 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kittystev

Does anybody know, is there a difference (if doctors' skill is not taken into account), in terms of final results, between open and closed rhinoplasty? I mean does it heal faster or looks better if done with closed? Does closed work better on noses with little improvement needed and open for noses which need a lot of correction? Because there are only two types of surgeons: those performing open rhino and those performing closed rhino (the last say they also perform open rhino, but only on difficult cases, which is almost 5%). I wouldn't say my nose is difficult, but I would say it definitely needs more than a tiny correction

.
So, if anybody noticed a difference in the final outcome between the 2 procedures please let me know, it would be very helpful in making a decision on what type of surgeon should I pick for my rhino.

Hi, I just had my surgery yesterday and I had a closed rhinoplasty with an awesome surgeon. My nose was shortened, bump removed, and straightened. So, in other words, I had a lot of work done. Plus I had my deviated septum straightened b/c I couldn't breathe. He told me closed is better for primary surgery and the result is better. But again, do go to one that specializes in closed surgeries. Do check him out in terms of his credentials.

Ever since I woke up from the surgery I haven't had any pain whatsoever. I do feel some pressure as my face is swelling, but very minor. I am so happy it's all done and over with and I wouldn't doubt my decision to do it all over again. It was expensive but I saved my money and fortunately for me my mom paid half. I had it done in the doctor's private clinic only b/c I was allowed to stay over nigth with private care and wouldn't have to drive back to remove my packing. The removal of packing was a bit intense as it felt rather weird, but not painful. I will tell you one thing, DO look for a specialist in ONLY neck and head cosmetic surgery. Don't look for one that performs all these other ones as he's not specified and all-rounded in one area but all, which may limit his ability. My doctor was a specialist with artistic skills. I wish you much luck. If you have any questions, ask away.

blu_eyes11219 · 04-01-2004, 12:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by katty233

Hi, I just had my surgery yesterday and I had a closed rhinoplasty with an awesome surgeon. My nose was shortened, bump removed, and straightened. So, in other words, I had a lot of work done. Plus I had my deviated septum straightened b/c I couldn't breathe. He told me closed is better for primary surgery and the result is better. But again, do go to one that specializes in closed surgeries. Do check him out in terms of his credentials.

Ever since I woke up from the surgery I haven't had any pain whatsoever. I do feel some pressure as my face is swelling, but very minor. I am so happy it's all done and over with and I wouldn't doubt my decision to do it all over again. It was expensive but I saved my money and fortunately for me my mom paid half. I had it done in the doctor's private clinic only b/c I was allowed to stay over nigth with private care and wouldn't have to drive back to remove my packing. The removal of packing was a bit intense as it felt rather weird, but not painful. I will tell you one thing, DO look for a specialist in ONLY neck and head cosmetic surgery. Don't look for one that performs all these other ones as he's not specified and all-rounded in one area but all, which may limit his ability. My doctor was a specialist with artistic skills. I wish you much luck. If you have any questions, ask away.

Who was your surgeon?

katty233 · 04-01-2004, 06:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blu_eyes11219

Who was your surgeon?

I had my surgery done in toronto. Dr. K. Conrad.

semih · 04-02-2004, 01:37 AM

hello, i just read your mail. You wrote that, your doctor was Dr. K. Conrad in Toronto. I have been thinking Dr. Solomon in Toronto. Becouse of his cost is cheaper. Have you ever heard him? Do you recommend him?
tahnk you very much