Hi JAG - Well, my belly button looks great! It is an "inny" and looks completely natural. The thing is that it was a bit hard to get used to since I was born with a different-looking one. There were tiny little sutures all around the circumference of the belly button which the doc removed when I had the big stitches from the tummy tuck removed. The belly button is nice and tight since all the surrounding skin is nice and tight. If I look dead center into a mirror, the only thing is that the bb is not right in the middle of my body, just a bit, a very tiny bit, off to the right. Is that me just expecting perfection? Well, after paying what I did for this little procedure (most insurance co. don't pay for it since it is considered cosmetic although in my case it was affecting my posture), I expected perfection!!
Hope this helps you out!

Any more questions, just ask!!! Are you thinking about doing this?