Hello Nifty -
I have the exact same condition you describe. I've been told by several Drs that I need to have either a fusion, which is a permanent fix with a long recovery or a procedure which removes a portion of the joint and cleans up the bone spurs, etc. It is called a Keller Bunionectomy and this is what I have chosen to have. My surgery is scheduled for Mon. June 23rd....
I a spent a ton of time researching and fussing about what to do. In reality, I found a POD I like and feel very comfortable with. He has done this procedure on a women I know (both feet) and she is doing very well. It may not be the best procedure for a very young, active individual and if it fails, you have no other option but a fusion. Since I am 66, I feel it's worth the chance. I am very active and try to walk 45 minutes daily..Apparently this procedure leaves you with a shorter floppy toe. In doing so, you lose some of the "purchase" or "push off" power in your foot and this in turn stresses the other toes which are smaller, etc. My Dr. makes special orthotics to help support this problem and claims he is has had great success with this. Out of 6 PODs I consulted, 3 recommend the Keller Procedure. The Ortho. Surgeon recommended the fusion but doesn't do them. Referred me to another POD in the area....Other recommendations were to perform just a cheilectomy but Dr's did admit I had no cartiledge left and this would be a temporary quick fix that might last me a few years. At that pint, a fusion would be necessary. An implant was another recommendation but I definitely don't want to fuss with one of those at my age. Outcome is too iffy...
I am getting a bit nervous as the surgery day approaches. I am worried that something could go wrong and I will be worse off than I am at the present. My foot IS very sore but not all day. I am limited to using icky old sneakers with orthotics and continuous cortisone injections that wear off in a few months. This is getting me down...so - I am making my final preparations for a boring 3-4 week recovery. Dr. hopes I'll be in a shoe in 3 weeks. Wouldn't that be nice!
I'll keep notes for you and let you know how I do. One good thing, the procedure only takes 35 minutes! Hooray.....I'll only miss one cup of coffe in the morning.....ha !
Good luck in your decision.....