I had mortons neuroma surgery done in my left foot 5 months ago and they also removed the nerve. I was experiencing an occasional electric tingle sensation, but it seems to have gone away now. Don't know exactly what causes it. Seems weird that yours would flare up after 5 years.
When you had your nerve removed with your neuroma surgery, did you toes remain numb? That was I am experiencing along with tightness at the incision area as well as a little soreness on ball of foot, right underneath incision area. My pod says it can take up to a year for everything to "settle down". How long was the full recovery for you?
Sharon