If it's a water tight toy, and I think it can survive, I put it in the dishwasher. Otherwise, I do antibacterial dish soap and water.
I do have some toys (blocks) that my 2 1/2 plus year old recently spread her poop all over (sorry if TMI) and for that I will be soaking it in Lysol and rinsing it repeatedly. I have no choice for that though. For me, it's either the Lysol or throwing the toys out.
I filled the sink with warm soapy water and soaked then washed everything that wasn't cloth. I then used a wet sponge and washed the surface for cloth toys then sprayed with lysol. I work in daycare and the way we do it there is wash stuffed animals in washing machine and use a very diluted bleach spray bottle to spray all surfaces such as shelves, walker or anythng baby puts hands and mouth on. Dont use the bleach on cloth surfaces it will turn it white/red spots.
Thank you all so much! I appreciate all the input. i got the anywhere spray, I love it. I had some before but kind of forgot about it after I used it up. My ds was just sick this past weekend and I got some lysol too but not for toys. My dh ended up getting REALLY sick too and I sprayed it everywhere! Thanks again.