It appears you have not yet Signed Up with our community. To Sign Up for free, please click here....



Knee & Hip Problems Message Board
Post New Thread   Closed Thread
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 08-25-2008, 08:10 PM   #1
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Red face Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Hey folks!

I filled him in on what happened, and how my knee cap was out of its groove and how it jumped back in there all by itself.

But since then, I've had swelling and patella slippage.

He is sending me for MRI.

He says he is looking for sprain or tear of the medical retiniculum. He says that it provides stability for the knee cap and the MRI will tell us just how bad it is...and will tell us weather I'll need surgery.

Anyone ever have medial retiniculum surgery here?

Any insights would be most appreciated..

Thanks!!!!!

~S

 
Old 09-14-2008, 10:00 PM   #2
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Just wanted to update even though I haven't gotten any replies. So alone in this thing... The OS in his grand indifference, said the X-rays and the MRI looked excellent.

So....he wouldn't speculate as to the reason for the severity of my knee pain or the source of the clunking. He merely agreed to write me a script for PT...and he was out of there.

I read all the horror stories, which sound so sad and long standing.

I hope the PT folks are more interested in my welfare than my doctor.

Thanks for listening.

~Soft

 
Sponsors Lightbulb
   
Old 09-15-2008, 01:19 PM   #3
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 5,070
katlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Soft,

A question...when the doc said your MRI looks excellent, does this mean that it doesn't show any damage or injury? Also, if you're not satisfied with the way this OS is treating you, or you think he is disinterested in your wellbeing, why don't you go to a different OS for a second opinion?

 
Old 09-15-2008, 07:21 PM   #4
Senior Member
(female)
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Ontario,Canada
Posts: 219
leeann123456 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Do you have knee pain constantly now and do certain things make it worse if you do?

 
Old 09-16-2008, 08:08 AM   #5
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Leanne and kmit:

Thanks so much for your replies. They mean the world to me...

Okay...to answer the first question. I had gone in telling him my patella had dislocated and that it was now slipping and there was a lot of pain and swelling.

When I got back to see him after the MRI was taken...he turned and said to me "Unfortunately, your Patella looks excellent" He further clarified saying that the retinaculum didn't even look stretched, nevermind shredded or anything like that.

The attitude struck me as pretty odd...using the word "unfortunately..."

According to him the minor ACL sprain the MRI showed, was old...so that couldn't be a factor in my pain or swelling. Interestingly...I have never injured myself before that I can recall, and you would think that I would have noticed it...so that is just another confusing thing.

The backstory is that I had seen him months back with an injury to the other knee. He is a injury prevention specialist who is the sports doctor director to the women's husky basketball team.

That knee injury was REALLY bad. I was limping terribly, as I couldn't flex the knee or the foot VERY swollen. I saw him twice regarding that injury and he never once explained the danger of opposing limb injury, (which is why this injury occurred), so when I went back to see him with this knee injury I let him know how I felt about that.

Now that this has happened people are quick to tell me that opposing knee injuries are "common." You would think that after all the money you pay out for appointments and doctor appointments...someone would inform you BEFORE it happens.

I've tried to just stay with one doc as the first leg injury was started a year and half ago, which was worsened by two previous doctors...and I'm still very much recovering still from those injuries when this new one came along.

So now, I'm just plain old laid up not able to enjoy the tiniest things in life, and to think that it all started because I went to the doctor over a minor tendinitis near my knee just kills me.

As far as the pain....it seems as though the pain is only if I attempt to walk on it now or if I touch the knee. I did have swelling that caused nerve pain up to my waist, but with icing that seems to be reduced now.

I've kept it braced or wrapped now for about five weeks. I'm using a crutch. I decided to do that because of what I read on line, not because the doctor thought I should. He made no suggestions what so ever...actually.

I have pain in the joint line and sharp pains around the knee cap itself.

Still it looks like I might just see another OS just to for a second opinion since this whole chain of events doesn't look right to me.

Thanks....I just can't help being really, really sad about this.

~soft

 
Old 09-16-2008, 08:18 PM   #6
Senior Member
(female)
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Ontario,Canada
Posts: 219
leeann123456 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

I've had a bad experience before with a surgeon making BOTH my knees worse. I've had knee pain since i was about 12 years old I'm currently 17, i had complained about it to my doctor and well thought nothing of it, do these stretches to strengthen your muscles and you should be alright. Well that of course did nothing. So after i finally gave up all my favourite things like soccer,roller blading, biking you name it i couldn't do it! The pain took over my life!
I finally got into see a orthopedic surgeon i was told he was the "best you can find in my area". I also got an MRI before i saw him. Well i get there well he didn't pay attention to me or care what pain i had. His residents saw me and spent more time playing around with my knee than he did! They never pulled up my mri to look at it or told me exactly what was on my MRI report! He never treated me like what i said mattered! But anyways, i wasn't to happy after that all i got told was get a brace and physio your knee cap isn't in the groove right. Not real information was given to me on what the heck this man was talking about. I was about to burst into tears sitting on that bed after he left it was maddening!
So i started my 3 months of physio like i was suppose to! Well after a month didn't my knee cap now start to SLIP! The worst pain ever. And not only that it damaged my right knee also. But if it wasn't for my physio therapist then i wouldn't have known what my knee issue was called which is lateral patella tracking. I have it in BOTH my knees.
I finally gave up and said forget it i will go see a surgeon i know is good at what he does and he DOES care! I saw him a week after asking for an appointment. Well my options pretty much were surgery. He wanted to scope it because the fact i had tried physio. I had a lateral release done to move my knee cap back! I've gone to a GREAT physio therapy place this time around, and after a slight relapse my left knee has been amazing! my right knee is up next in the next year!

I had swelling within the back of my knee and it bruised up quite lovely! All the normal symptoms of my issue i didn't really half the time notice. I'd walk with a very bad limp it was like my knee just didn't work normally! Most of my pain was in through the back of my knee! Which is why i had a very hard time believing it was all from my knee cap being out! It was extremely painful, and stairs would kill me, it wasn't the pain it was the fact of just how slow i actually did have to go or else it would just want to give out! I've learned one thing especially is that these doctors can not feel the pain and what your feeling, they can only go by what you say, so if they can't listen or aren't helping you have to find the help yourself because you know yourself the best!

 
Old 09-16-2008, 08:32 PM   #7
Member
(female)
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 74
reyez HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

You know it is sad that doctors just dont take their patients seriously.. I have went to my family doctor a few times reguarding my knee cap that slips out.. he would do x-rays & said that everything was fine.. He would always say that my knee cap dislocating was normal.. ha ha.. no.... I didnt even know what a MRI was or anything. I finally went back when I hurt myself & my doctor thought it was patellar tracking.. I went to see my Ortho surgeon and he thinks it is a meniscus tear.. I find out tomarrow what it really is.. my ortho surgeon said that my knee cap is slipping because of my knee being swollen.. that may be true... however, it has done this on & off for the past 3 years.. hard to believe that my knee can swell up for no reason.. I am hoping I get some good news tomarrow.. I would definitly get a second opinion. I didnt get into the doctor I wanted to so I am not sure on how I feel about him yet.. this will be my second time seeing him. The ortho I wanted to see was booked up for a month & I needed to be seen bad. I hope both of you are feeling better & can get some answers.

 
Old 09-16-2008, 08:45 PM   #8
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 5,070
katlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

I know this will probably not win me a popularity contest...but I don't think it's right to lump all docs into a not caring group. I have 3 orth surgeons, all at Duke med center and they're great, I wouldn't trade them for anything. I realize that sometimes you do get docs that don't care, but there are just as many out there that do. Sometimes you just have to keep looking to find one that fits you. Honestly to both of you, if you're that dissatisfied with your doc's, why don't you find a new one? Because you both seem to know that it's not going to get any better.

I do realize that the stress of not knowing what's wrong can make you very sad. I have dealt with degenerative cartiledge disease and osteoarthritis since I was 17 and I am now 39. I have had 10 surgeries, the last one being 3 weeks ago to reconstruct my knee with an tibial tubercle osteotomy. Basically they had to cut my tibia loose raise it 1mm, move it 2mm to the right, do bone grafts on each side and screw it down from the top. So, yeah bad knees do suck and they can be hard to work on, but if you find the right doc, they can be fixed.

Good luck to both of you.

 
Old 09-17-2008, 12:31 PM   #9
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Leann:

Wow...what a heartbreaking story. I'm very sorry to hear you went through all that. Yes...your point is well taken there that a person can only know their own pain and the doctors don't.

You say that you have Great therapy. What do you consider the hallmark of great therapy. I'm about to start with a therapist, and I'd like some insights on knowing what to look for in a good therapist.

Thanks...eversomuch for sharing the story. I do hope your other leg works out as well as the first.

I have read about the lateral release surgery and not all of it is positive, so its really great that it worked out for you!


~S

 
Old 09-17-2008, 01:02 PM   #10
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Kmit:

Wow...you have certainly been through a lot of surgeries! That is amazing.... My heart goes out to you and its sounds like you are working with some very professional docs. This is excellent and inspiring.

Your point is well taken...the docs are not universally bad. Still, all it takes is one bad doc to ruin your life and leave you in a lot of pain.

If I had to do it over again, I would have not got into a doctors office without a friend, and I would have gotten creative about making that happen if I had to. Unfortunately, even if you sense the danger, your friends might not...since its not them that will get injured or have their life destroyed. That only means they need some creative persuasion. Too bad I didn't get creative....and I really regret now that I was such a fool.

Now...of course that I'm so injured, my friendships were killed. Can't work or take a shower. So...nice downward spiral.... The days just running into one another with so little change...

If I had only been creative...

I called the PT place today to ask them if I should come over to see them for evaluation. Since I'm so wrecked, I fear that they will tell me they can't help me, or that my swelling is too extreme (it goes from my feet to my chest). The doctor didn't write anything much out on the PT sheet, so I had to explain why that was the case. I fear that they will touch me, or try to make me move in ways that will foster more problems for me...

Do you know if they will want to SEE my legs? Will they want to touch them? Will they poke and palpitate them...where the pain is the worst? I'm scared because EVERY doctor I have been to has contributed to my downfall...and I don't want to be a fool and offer anyone else the opportunity to make me worse. I can't even look at my legs right now...I'm so emotional about them.

I guess I worry about having also missed out on getting good info from doctors and was hoping they could fill in the blanks for me with a few things, and that they could help me to NOT atrophy....if its possible without injuring me. So..I'm trying to be measured in my search for wellness..safely.

Its hard to try now. Its been such a nightmare. I just want to know that there is a light at the end of the tunnel.

You guys are so great...so inspiring and full of great info. Thanks again for sharing.

~S

 
Old 09-17-2008, 03:23 PM   #11
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Killer:

I can't wait to see what they say you have. Patella tracking or meniscus....you could have both. That would really be bad..

Yeah...the swelling and the maltracking thing seems kind of strange.. I thought the same thing about mine. I thought...if I could eliminate the swelling the slipping would stop...but then again, I started to worry that the slipping WAS causing the swelling though annoyance of the surrounding tissues. OY!

Still...if the patella is not tracking, my understanding is that it needs to be addressed, and that could mean PT, or surgery or both. Sheesh....

Is this doc doing an MRI for you. They say an MRI will show how disrupted the ligaments that hold the patella in place are. They can be stretched or torn...or not show anything at all. MRIs can be under read...meaning they don't necessarily show things in the kind of true detail that they really are. When it comes to patella...the tracking is best evaluated by CT scan at various degrees to see the flex points of maltrackage. I've read that anyway...as a static picture of a motion joint...doesn't always tell whole story. I just read that yesterday...so it might be rarely done.

~S

 
Old 09-17-2008, 10:11 PM   #12
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 5,070
katlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB Userkatlin09 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

Soft,

It doesn't show where you live, but if you live near a University or teaching hospital...then a second opnion buy a new Ortho Surgeon would definitely be warranted. These type of practices are generally the best docs. And yes your observation of CatScans being rarely done for knee problems was correct, MRI's are the standard test and they show the pattala tracking with no problems. Now as far as PT goes, yes they will touch your legs in order to work whatever excercises they deem necesary to fix the problem. There also could be palpatation of the knee cap if that is warranted. A TENS unit might be applied for the nerve pain and probably icing for the swelling, it just depends on what your doc prescribes. And if the orders aren't clear enough, they will most likely contact the docs office to check what they should do. Are you on any kind of medicine regiment to help control the pain? I know this type of injury can be painful, but it definitely should not be as debilitating as you have described. I would really think about getting a second opinion.

 
Old 09-18-2008, 10:50 AM   #13
Member
(female)
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 74
reyez HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

SoftCrush- My doc gave me the results.. I have a tracking problem with my knee cap. He gave me a cortisone shot ( his idea) and said to come back in 4 weeks. He said that if the cortisone shot doesnt help then he will do an arthoscopic lateral release surgery. He said my knee is really really swollen.. and he said I have some roughness on the back of my knee which he said he will scrape off if/when he does the surgery.. I have to say the cortisone has helped the pain.. not 100% but has helped its just super sore from the shot.. It is still very unstable but I am trying my hardest to stay off of it. I have had this problem for 3 years.. It wasnt really bad until recently the past few months.. My family doctor had told me that it was normal for it to slip out.. Not knowing I thought he was right since he was the doctor. Now I know to get a second opinion if I ever have questions.. I just am glad to have some answers. I have an appt on Oct 21.. and I will find out what we do from there..

He just did a MRI on me but he was able to see all of that on a MRI.. I know not everything can be seen on a MRI though..

 
Old 09-18-2008, 02:23 PM   #14
Inactive
(female)
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 600
softcrush HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

KAT:

It sounds like you are so on target with things. Really appreciate your contribution here.

I just got back from the PT place and unfortunately it didn't go well. The young woman seemed to be on a war stance from the outset, and my questions got her really worked up. She started screaming over me while she had me lying on the exam table that my distrust issues are not from something she did, and that my reluctance to move my legs like she asked, showed I wasn't ready for help.

I was told that I should go home and think about it, and call back with my decision.

I'm unfamiliar with a tens unit...so that might be interesting. Is there some things I could buy that might help do you think?

Re: other things you mention.

The PT woman had told me that MRI doesn't show everything last time I was there, but today she told me that if my doc had ordered PT and that the MRI showed everything as being healthy, then there was no way there was anything wrong. It was such a strange and obvious contradiction.

She also said being active rids you of swelling after injury, and yet as I have done RICE, the swelling has reduced....so what she was saying seemed to be out of step with my experience. I had tried to be active with my patella slipping and it CREATED swelling...and she said that since that was weeks ago...it doesn't mean it will happen now. Besides she said...this slippage complaint was only "according" to me -- not a verifiable fact.

I've only just gotten rid of the worst pain in my knee a couple days ago (keeping the leg straight with a wrap, and crutching around)...but she insists that this was nothing to do with the injury. She said the pain is from the lack of ROM. The thing is...I'm trying to let the healing take place...it's not that I CAN'T flex it.

My ankle is also sore...so I'm trying to stay off that as well and I try to keep that in a bandage and protected. Before she understood that...she proclaimed with high invective that my knee was affecting my ankle now. LOL I explained...the ankle was badly swollen from old scar tissue when my dog jumped on it....months ago. Its still healing and painful. She wanted to know if I saw anyone about it...and I said I mentioned it to my doc...but that he didn't take an interest in it.

She seemed annoyed at me for that too...

Its been a non-stop train wreck...and I don't know where it ends. I only know that I either got to try another PT place or another doc...or both. Maybe I should hold off on PT until the swelling is in better shape...and THEN try to get to PT?

I still don't know what PT involves. If the cornerstone of PT is palpation for documentation purposes...(which I know will injure me right now...and/or flexing my patella out of place), I think I should hold off until I heal better. I just wish someone could simply coach/support me through safe patella building moves...rather than run a strict document driven agenda on me while yelling in my face. I want to regain my life without further injury. Apparently that is terribly offensive to some people.

Do you know of a type of therapy or a type of sports wellness coaching like that?

My leg hurts more now that she has been monkeying around with it...and I'm SAD. I've cried endlessly over this, and you would think someone might understand how I feel, but apparently I'm just bringing out the worst in everyone.

YES..Kat...I do take advil and I do a lot of icing. All day and night... The doctor didn't mention any of that, but I read on-line that these things could be helpful....and so far they have been. Its just taking a long time.

~S

 
Old 09-18-2008, 02:47 PM   #15
Senior Member
(female)
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Ontario,Canada
Posts: 219
leeann123456 HB User
Re: Back from OS regarding patella dislocation

softcrush! If there is one thing i have learned is in order to do well in physio you need to find one you trust completely! that is definitely where i went wrong with my first physio therapist! They left me on machines doing things wrong and these things all caused more damage!
I found an amazing physio therapist through websites online! I scouted out the best because i wanted someone who wasn't going to get mad at me or not go by how i felt! I just got released from my physio program last night! I wouldn't have finished that program after having my surgery if i stuck with the place i was at before hand! Its the environment that makes all the difference! I don't know how much of a help saying this is! But i would go with your gut! i know i have been told you can't ignore it! You have to do something about it or it can get worse, but if you need PT find a place that works with you. the PT's are suppose to be there to inform the patients and answer the question you want to know!

 
Closed Thread

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Board Replies Last Post
Knee and Back pain... Hopeful Wishes Knee & Hip Problems 2 10-04-2010 06:45 AM
Knee pops out, then back in-please help montyinthehouse Knee & Hip Problems 13 06-07-2010 10:10 AM
Patella subluxation Ashleyj9222 Knee & Hip Problems 28 01-28-2009 11:09 PM
patella injury enchantedfairy Knee & Hip Problems 2 08-08-2008 11:22 PM
Chondromalacia Patella/Patella Femoral Pain Syndrome macs4life06 Knee & Hip Problems 6 07-30-2008 09:19 AM




Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off




Join Our Newsletter

Stay healthy through tips curated by our health experts.

Whoops,

There was a problem adding your email Try again

Thank You

Your email has been added








TOP THANKED CONTRIBUTORS



SweetPeainSF (48), janewhite1 (47), Silver Swan (31), jennybyc (26), SpineAZ (24), Grumpyathome (21), james079 (20), ldy12 (19), glennxyz (17), tiredbeinsick (17)

Site Wide Totals

teteri66 (1180), MSJayhawk (1004), Apollo123 (904), Titchou (847), janewhite1 (823), Gabriel (759), ladybud (754), sammy64 (668), midwest1 (668), BlueSkies14 (610)



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:01 PM.



Site owned and operated by HealthBoards.comô
Terms of Use © 1998-2014 HealthBoards.comô All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!