Hi there, I think what the school is doing is definitely punishment. Overloading your child with schoolwork is definitely going to harm more that help. Is you child receiving sp. services. If not you should check into it. Not having pe or recess will definitley be construed by your child as punishment. You don't want him to shut down, Esp. with reading. I am currently having my child ld tested. His teacher is very understanding. She suggested modifying his assigments. This keeps his self confidence up and he is still learning. Good luck