Does Rogaine work? - Men's Health Message Board

Shel · 10-05-2001, 07:40 AM

Has anyone here tried Rogaine? My husband has thinning hair, mostly in the top back. We bought a 3 month supply of Rogaine and I was wondering if it worked for anyone here. Thanks.

orion · 11-17-2001, 10:05 PM

I think the virdict is that Rogaine doesn't work for most men, but it does for some. However, Propecia does work for about 60% of men. It is also possible that Saw Palmetto will also work since it has been shown to have the same properties as propecia.

Shel · 11-19-2001, 07:21 AM

Orion,

Thanks for the reply. Saw Palmetto? What's that? An Herbal Supplement? Our doctor said Propecia has sexual side effects and isn't worth it. Does Saw Palmetto have sexual side effects also??'

Thanks,

Shel

Babernethy · 11-21-2001, 08:40 AM

I have not met anyone that Rogaine worked for...I tried the 5% version for 8 months...no difference. I am now on Propecia. If you punch it up on the internet you will find that the side effects are minimal and only affect about 2.5% of men who take it. The info also says it is more likely to affect men who have had sexual problems in the past. If your hubby is healthy, like I am, he should experience no more side effects than I have (none!) It is costing me about $50.00 per month...I have 3 months supply and then I will see the doctor for Liver function. This is standard practice. If everything is OK, I'll be issued a prescription for a year. Propecia is supposed to start working after the 6 month point. We'll have to see as the JURY is still out.
B

orion · 11-21-2001, 09:59 PM

Your doctor is just being cautious so you won't sue him. There can be side effects, but if they show up, you can just stop taking the medications. Ask you doctor what is wrong with doing that?

Saw Palmetto, is the herbal equivalent of Propecia. The verdict is still out on how well either of these really work in the long run. It's worth a try though.