My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
I just got the news that my doctor will no longer see me after October 1st, 2009. He told me they can no longer accept Worker's Comp because it's too much paperwork and not enough money for them. I feel like I was dumped in favor of money. I wasn't given enough time to find a new doctor in time.
The problem is that he's been filling my pain med prescriptions for the entire time and I had a really hard time finding him in the first place. Before finding him, I had gone to 5 other Dr's and pain management centers and 3 of them accused me of drug seeking and the other 2 said they would take me on as a patient, but they wouldn't fill my scripts which would have been worthless.
Here's a little history just to give you an idea of my current condition.
5/10/98 I hurt my back while lifting boxes at work.
8/2000 After continuing to work after my injury I had to stop when my legs went numb and my back pain got to be so bad I couldn't stand it.
8/17/2000 I had an emergency discectomy/laminectomy of the L5/S1.
11/2000 I had an infection in the disk space that was operated on.
6/22/2001 Another back surgery - micro discectomy & biopsy
4/16/2002 3rd back surgery - Spinal fusion + cage
4/13/2006 Spinal Cord Stimulator implant
I have been on pain meds since my first surgery and currently take
100mq Duragesic patches 1/every 2 days
7.5/325mg Percocet MDD 8
350mg Soma (muscle relaxers) MDD 4
75mg/25mg Lyrica
+various Rx stomach meds, Vit D, Androgel
I am having trouble locating a new doctor who will even take Worker's Comp let alone fill all these medications for me. Along with all the pain I'm in constantly, now I stressed out that I won't find someone who will continue this. The meds I currently take are just keep me at baseline.. if I have to stop any of it and cut back I don't know how I'll be able to deal with it.
Does anyone have any tips on finding a new doctor that accepts Comp and have them continue where the last doctor left off? There have been so many doctors in this area that have lost their licenses revoked by the DEA. I guess I don't blame the doctors for being afraid to treat with pain meds.
Thanks for taking the time to read this,
Matt (upstate NY, USA)
The Following User Says Thank You to spoonmanx For This Useful Post: alonzo1989 (05-07-2012)
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
That is disgraceful
A few thoughts (I am in Australia, so things are different here) but...
Is he refering you on to another pain specialist? Is it ethical for him to simply abandon you? Ring the state medical board and ask for help, they might atleast be able to offer you names of other pain specialists.
Can you pay cash for you visits while searching for another pain management doctor?
Do you have a family physician who will prescribe for you?
Very glad we dont have a DEA type orgainisation here overseeing prescribing of medical narcotics.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Spoon, have you thought about going thru work comp? Make them find you a decent doctor? I'm not sure of all that you have been thru on that end but if that is the prob and your work comp is still on going... make them help you, or your case manager. Just my 2 cents. I hope u feel better, I'm not at the same level you are at, but I do understand. Truly I do. Mine is my neck and getting worse instead of better... May we both feel better someday...
Last edited by MCandyG; 09-20-2009 at 02:19 AM.
Reason: responded to wrong person...
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
I feel like I was dumped in favor of money. I wasn't given enough time to find a new doctor in time.
Unfortunately, you are being dumped due to money. Whatever happened to the medical oath of "do no harm"? I'd try to get in front of this Doc ASAP and see if he could at least see you until you are properly transitioned. I would remind him that fentanyl is the strongest pain med out there and one just doesn't stop taking it. I'd make him look me in the eye and tell me that he's dropping me or say "no" to some type of continuing care.
Or, you could tell them that you'll just pay cash or bill it to regular insurance from here on out. You could do this permanently, or until you get transitioned. If you don't have insurance, you might ask him that given your long term patient history with him, could you work out some type of deal....Something reasonable so you can continue on as a patient.
Quote:
The problem is that he's been filling my pain med prescriptions for the entire time and I had a really hard time finding him in the first place. Before finding him, I had gone to 5 other Dr's and pain management centers and 3 of them accused me of drug seeking and the other 2 said they would take me on as a patient, but they wouldn't fill my scripts which would have been worthless.
All of this is the past, and I wouldn't tell too many people this, especially prospective Docs, nurses, or appointment people. Unfortunately, the field of PM is of edge right now, and you don't want to scare anyone off. You've had a good record for seven years which is a long time in PM. I'm not suggesting that you did anything improper.....There is no need to mention the other stuff....It just clouds the water. If anyone asks about your prior medical treatment, just tell them that it took you a bit of time to find a good Doc and don't give any details.
Quote:
I am having trouble locating a new doctor who will even take Worker's Comp let alone fill all these medications for me.
The problem is that workers comp has become a nightmare to deal with....Constant paperwork and updates. They do this on purpose so people get frustrated and drop off....Just like what's happening to you.
I would first get my Doc straightened away re: accepting regular insurance and / or cash until I got transitioned. Then, I would write & call my congressman, state senators, and the President. I'd copy my Doc on everything. Make the Doc look like the hero and bash workers comp and the insurance industry. It's a hot topic right now. Also, maybe your Doc will hang in there once he sees his name copied on all these letters....I doubt he'd want his name up in lights.
Take care, and I hope this all works out for you.
Regards,
Ex
Last edited by Executor; 09-20-2009 at 07:19 AM.
The Following User Says Thank You to Executor For This Useful Post: gliickie (03-17-2012)
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by MCandyG
Spoon, have you thought about going thru work comp? Make them find you a decent doctor? I'm not sure of all that you have been thru on that end but if that is the prob and your work comp is still on going... make them help you, or your case manager. Just my 2 cents. I hope u feel better, I'm not at the same level you are at, but I do understand. Truly I do. Mine is my neck and getting worse instead of better... May we both feel better someday...
Thanks and good luck with your pain. I am still hopeful even after 11 years of pain.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Hi Ex, thanks for the reply.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Executor
Unfortunately, you are being dumped due to money. Whatever happened to the medical oath of "do no harm"? I'd try to get in front of this Doc ASAP and see if he could at least see you until you are properly transitioned. I would remind him that fentanyl is the strongest pain med out there and one just doesn't stop taking it. I'd make him look me in the eye and tell me that he's dropping me or say "no" to some type of continuing care.
Or, you could tell them that you'll just pay cash or bill it to regular insurance from here on out. You could do this permanently, or until you get transitioned. If you don't have insurance, you might ask him that given your long term patient history with him, could you work out some type of deal....Something reasonable so you can continue on as a patient.
[/i]
All of this is the past, and I wouldn't tell too many people this, especially prospective Docs, nurses, or appointment people. Unfortunately, the field of PM is of edge right now, and you don't want to scare anyone off. You've had a good record for seven years which is a long time in PM. I'm not suggesting that you did anything improper.....There is no need to mention the other stuff....It just clouds the water. If anyone asks about your prior medical treatment, just tell them that it took you a bit of time to find a good Doc and don't give any details.
[/i]
The problem is that workers comp has become a nightmare to deal with....Constant paperwork and updates. They do this on purpose so people get frustrated and drop off....Just like what's happening to you.
I would first get my Doc straightened away re: accepting regular insurance and / or cash until I got transitioned. Then, I would write & call my congressman, state senators, and the President. I'd copy my Doc on everything. Make the Doc look like the hero and bash workers comp and the insurance industry. It's a hot topic right now. Also, maybe your Doc will hang in there once he sees his name copied on all these letters....I doubt he'd want his name up in lights.
Take care, and I hope this all works out for you.
Regards,
Ex
He seemed like a good and helpful doctor, but I guess it's a business and they must run it as such.
When he told me the news he avoided eye contact and seemed ashamed of it. He told me it was a hard decision.
I later received an official letter from him telling me I can continue to see him for other primary care
needs, just nothing W/C related. I don't want to continue to go there for anything after being let down like this.
The trouble with continuing with him, is they won't fill any future w/c related prescriptions so that's the problem.
I do have Medicare, but they don't pay for any of my worker's comp stuff since it's already established with Traveler's W/C
Thanks for the tips. I am going to make a lot of calls on Tuesday. Tomorrow (Monday) is my birthday and I don't want to deal with any of this for at least that single day. A small gift to myself I suppose. :P
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
I could pay cash for the visits, but I was told the pharmacy wouldn't be able to put the prescriptions through my comp and those would cost me roughly $3000 a month.. which obviously I can't do.
I'm not sure I understand. If you pay "cash" for the visits...or bill them to Medicare, why can't the pharmacy bill them to WC then? A Rx is an Rx.
Also, open enrollment in Medicare starts in October, and you could switch to a plan that would cover most, if not all of those meds. I don't think there are any pre-existing clauses that I'm aware of.
Quote:
The SCS is primarily used for radiating nerve pain which (most) all
patients understand. (Depends on what their docs tell them. It
appears from my research that some docs throw this at all kinds of
patients, as an option whether it really makes sense or not. If they
have run out of other ideas, they push this inappropriately.
I can certainly understand why you feel this way....I would feel the exact same way. However, I'd make another appointment to see him and practically beg if I had to. Tell him that this is everything to you and you doubt that you can get transitioned to another Doc. I'd even remind him of his "do no harm" oath that he took when he became a Dr. I'd ask him point blank...."what happened to 'do no harm'?
I'd ask him that since you're such a long time established patient, could you be "grandfathered" in? Again, I would beg, plead, do whatever I had to for him to keep you on. I know it's a lot of paperwork, but you're just one patient.....And you have a very complex situation and could be seriously harmed if not accepted by anyone.
I realize that not everyone would want to take this approach, but I would pull out all the stops. Even with the graveling, all he can do is say "no." And then, he has to live with himself if he follows through....He has to be able to sleep at night knowing the decision he is making. Simply "going away" makes life easier for him, and I wouldn't. Squeaky wheel gets the oil.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
How often do you have to see him for pain management? Could he issue with repeatable prescriptions, so that you could see him every 3 months or even 6 months, and pay cash for the visit.... that would be less of a burden than paying cash for every month, and it sounds like you have a stabal history.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
Thanks for the tips. I am going to make a lot of calls on Tuesday. Tomorrow (Monday) is my birthday and I don't want to deal with any of this for at least that single day. A small gift to myself I suppose. :P
Matt
I hope you have a great birthday today. I really do not have anything to add, but did want to say that I am sorry that this is happening to you. It just seems like this is happening more and more, whether it be your situation with WC or just offices' closing down, for whatever reason. I hope everything works out and I would speak to the DR about hopefully staying with him but paying cash. I hope something can be worked out, so you do not have to start over, if you can even find a dr in your area. Good luck!!
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
I had asked my doctor if I could continue with paying out of pocket or with Medicare and he told me that once his WC termintaion paperwork goes through, he will not be legally able to write prescriptions for anything worker's comp related. I don't know if he's just telling me that to avoid the extra paperwork or not.
Also, I couldn't afford to pay out of pocket since I know they charge $90/month for W/C so I assume it might be even more for a regular visit. I think that's a big reason why they are getting rid of W/C patients in the first place. They want more money. I am living on $500/month SSI (out of work for 9 years now) so even $90/month extra would put me in financial trouble.
From what I was told, if Medicare pays for the visit, then worker's comp will not pay for the medications. I checked out the Medicare Rx plan and it really doesn't help me much. I require the brand name meds for Percocet and Duragesic. Medicare only pays a majority for generics (when available).
I really don't think begging him to take me back is a good idea. Keep in mind, he was also my Primary Care doctor. I need a doctor I can trust my life with. He isn't that person anymore. I don't need a doctor that is just willing to accept my money. Maybe now I will find a doctor that can not only take over his duties, but might even do more for me than the last one. I don't know... I'm continuing to look.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
From what I was told, if Medicare pays for the visit, then worker's comp will not pay for the medications. I checked out the Medicare Rx plan and it really doesn't help me much.
That makes perfect sense....I think this information is correct. It's just a shame that he can't work out something for you, given your LT track record there.
At the very least, however, I'd ask (almost demand in a nice way) that he care for you until you are transitioned (maybe an extra month or two). He has taken the oath of "do not harm" and given the high level of fentanyl you're on, you could experience some severe problems if you don't stay on them, or are forced to WD. I would hope that he would at least give you some extended Rxs to get you through.
I don't mean to scare you, but your transition is critical.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Sorry if I've missed something here but are you still on workers comp? Don't they have some responsibility to make sure you still receive care? I'd be ringing them (my case manager) and explaining what's happened and asking them to find you someone asap or else they're going to have massive hospital bills when you go into wds. I would also ring every dr in my area (preferably PM) and asking if they take established (proven that you're not a seeker) workers comp patients. I'd also ask your doc to write a letter stating that you've been the perfect patient and he believes that you are at no risk of seeking and are simply looking for a PM dr. It's the least he can do for you.
Unfortunately money is a problem (and it's only getting worse for many with drugs like Actiq being taken off insurance for non cancer sufferers) so if it comes down to it you may need to get heavy with the WC company. You were injured at work so they have a responsibility to make sure that you're treated for anything WC related. This is a legal responsibility. I'd drop into my local congress/write to my senator and explain their breach of treatment and ask for help. If it gets really bad you could threaten media....
It is so unfair that you've been put in this situation. If I were you I'd do everything in my power to have my current doc (I know he's let you down) help, he needs to give you a letter to take to PM offices (better if you go in person - then you might be able to work out a small cash payment for the extra WC paperwork, or something). I'd also ask him straight up what happens when you've exhausted all your options and you can't find anyone to treat you - do you just go to hospital and explain that your doc won't treat you anymore? This wouldn't look good for him.
I live in Aus so it's a bit different - I was on WC and in the state I live in it only covers you for 9 years, pretty unfair, hey. I know what you're going through stress wise about how you're going to survive in the future. Thankfully I also had workers insurance and am counting on them (they'd better payout soon) to get me through. If you're still covered by WC then get on their backs...it's their fault that this has happened and they may possibly be able to work something out with your current doc - it'll be a lot cheaper for them if you stay with him rather than have a PM. Hopefully that alone might be enough to get them working for you rather than against you. No company wants the risk of more expense.
One more question, do you have a relationship with the PM that put in the SCS? Could you go to them for help? Just a thought.
Happy Birthday, I really wish you didn't have this stress at the moment.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jema X
Don't they have some responsibility to make sure you still receive care? I'd be ringing them (my case manager) and explaining what's happened and asking them to find you someone asap or else they're going to have massive hospital bills when you go into wds.
This is a great idea by Jema. Since WC has all these screwy rules, I'd put the squeeze on them. Maybe they can work with your Doc for less paperwork and etc. I have a friend who is on lifetime WC for a back problem, and they were requiring monthly reports. The PM Doc finally called them and said "hey...This isn't gonna change...It's forever....All this paperwork is just costing us both time and money" and they made some type of exception for him. I'd look into this.
Quote:
I'd also ask your doc to write a letter stating that you've been the perfect patient and he believes that you are at no risk of seeking and are simply looking for a PM dr. It's the least he can do for you.
At the very least, this is what your Doc should do. If he's truly dumping you for paperwork / financial reasons, he has some obligation to get you transitioned.
Quote:
It is so unfair that you've been put in this situation. If I were you I'd do everything in my power to have my current doc (I know he's let you down) help, he needs to give you a letter to take to PM offices (better if you go in person - then you might be able to work out a small cash payment for the extra WC paperwork, or something). I'd also ask him straight up what happens when you've exhausted all your options and you can't find anyone to treat you - do you just go to hospital and explain that your doc won't treat you anymore? This wouldn't look good for him.
Another great point by Jema....Especially the part about what happens after you've exhausted all your options. I'd ask him "Hypothetically, what if I end up in the hospital from all of this or worse" and then see what he says.....
I strongly feel you have to say these things to put it all back on him....He's put you in this situation, so he needs to understand the potential consequences.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Thanks Jema and Ex for your help.
My doctor is going to see me one last time on 9/30 to fill my scripts for October. He also said he is going to try and find someone for me to see.
I received a letter from his office saying they will not be able to see anyone other than for primary care services.. no future worker's comp will be allowed and there will be no exceptions. They are a smaller practice. Only 1 doctor and a handful of office help. I feel they already have too many patients and this is their way of weeding it out without losing the higher paying insurance carriers.
I will ask him to write a referral letter and request copies of my records as well. I have been making calls and the problem I keep encountering is many doctors are either not accepting new patients or if they are they won't accept new patients with w/c insurance.
I also contacted my local worker's compensation board to get assistance, but they aren't returning my calls.
They recently made a big mistake on my lawyer's request for a discogram test. They sat on it for 3 months and then filed it as a medical bill in need of payment which made no sense. Then I received another letter saying "The proposed decision in the W/C case was withdrawn as a result of an objection received by the Conciliation Bureau" So in short.. I don't think they are going to be much help.
Again, thanks for the help. I will keep you posted on my progress.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
My take on all of this is that the doctor has probably cut ties to WC because of the lousy pay schedule, along with the fact that it takes doctors up to 90 days to receive payment from WC insurance carriers. Subtle threats about "what happens if I end up in the hospital......" are really unfair. While it is true that doctors take an oath of do no harm, they are also in business. Sometimes people lose site of that. Their training leaves them deeply in debt, and with a lot of the HMO's and other set insurance policies, their pay is actually going down - especially when you factor in malpractice insurance, etc. I'd say the letter of recommendation is an excellent idea, and if he's really willing to help you locate another doctor, he's a decent guy - many doctors would just say "so long." Good luck.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
My doctor is going to see me one last time on 9/30 to fill my scripts for October. He also said he is going to try and find someone for me to see.
I don't mean to beat a dead horse, but when you go in, you really should push him for helping you get transitioned. Depending on how he comes across, I'd be prepared to get a little rough with him....Something along the lines of "you put me on these big time meds and now you're dropping me for only financial reasons and now I could have severe health consequences"...Something like that. You may want to even throw his own pledge back at him of "do no harm." That may really get his attention.
I'd also press him for as many refills as it takes to get transitioned.
I really hope he helps you. He owes you at least that. The reality of the matter is that with one phone call, he should be able to get you in to see one of his colleagues. PM is a small world and all the Docs know each other really well.
Best of luck with this. Sorry if I'm coming across tough with this one....This has really bothered me.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by daveseavy
My take on all of this is that the doctor has probably cut ties to WC because of the lousy pay schedule, along with the fact that it takes doctors up to 90 days to receive payment from WC insurance carriers. Subtle threats about "what happens if I end up in the hospital......" are really unfair. While it is true that doctors take an oath of do no harm, they are also in business. Sometimes people lose site of that. Their training leaves them deeply in debt, and with a lot of the HMO's and other set insurance policies, their pay is actually going down - especially when you factor in malpractice insurance, etc. I'd say the letter of recommendation is an excellent idea, and if he's really willing to help you locate another doctor, he's a decent guy - many doctors would just say "so long." Good luck.
I understand that W/C has been putting more pressure on doctors and they may not make as much money as with one of the other insurance companies, but from what I heard he collects more from a W/C case than with a Medicare or Medicaid patient. That probably also explains why he didn't suggest I continue to see him as strictly as a primary care patient since my other insurance is Medicare.
Here's the thing though. He's ALWAYS been paid for every single visit over the last 7+ years. In fact there has been a few visits where he has charged both W/C and Medicare $90 for a single visit (which I think might be illegal).
I understand about his practice being a business, but like I mentioned, my visits rarely run longer than 5 minutes and all the scripts are printed automatically, so it's not like he has to sit there and write a ton of scripts for me or explain anything new to me. It just seems 5 minutes of his time + some paperwork (done by a receptionist is worth $90 to him. I guess I am wrong though.
When you go to the same guy for over 7 years you build trust and don't except something like this. I referred about 20 people to him, including my mother, who is continuing to see him.
Some people do become doctors because they want to help people. It's just hard to find them sometimes.
I have to agree with Ex on this. I don't think it's wise for him to cut me loose when I'm on medications, that if stopped cold turkey, can kill me! He's dropping me because of money. Not because I did anything wrong and not because he has no other choice. I think he owes it to me to make sure I find someone to take over the prescriptions at the very least (if I can't find someone on my own)
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by spoonmanx
I understand that W/C has been putting more pressure on doctors and they may not make as much money as with one of the other insurance companies, but from what I heard he collects more from a W/C case than with a Medicare or Medicaid patient. That probably also explains why he didn't suggest I continue to see him as strictly as a primary care patient since my other insurance is Medicare.
Here's the thing though. He's ALWAYS been paid for every single visit over the last 7+ years. In fact there has been a few visits where he has charged both W/C and Medicare $90 for a single visit (which I think might be illegal).
I understand about his practice being a business, but like I mentioned, my visits rarely run longer than 5 minutes and all the scripts are printed automatically, so it's not like he has to sit there and write a ton of scripts for me or explain anything new to me. It just seems 5 minutes of his time + some paperwork (done by a receptionist is worth $90 to him. I guess I am wrong though.
When you go to the same guy for over 7 years you build trust and don't except something like this. I referred about 20 people to him, including my mother, who is continuing to see him.
Some people do become doctors because they want to help people. It's just hard to find them sometimes.
I have to agree with Ex on this. I don't think it's wise for him to cut me loose when I'm on medications, that if stopped cold turkey, can kill me! He's dropping me because of money. Not because I did anything wrong and not because he has no other choice. I think he owes it to me to make sure I find someone to take over the prescriptions at the very least (if I can't find someone on my own)
-Matt
Just keep on him to help you find another doctor. I can understand your feelings - it's like abandonment. But it is what it is, and the best thing to do now is get another doctor lined up so that the transition is as sooth as possible.
Re: My doctor is cutting ties after 7 years of pain management. I need advice ASAP!
Quote:
Originally Posted by daveseavy
Just keep on him to help you find another doctor. I can understand your feelings - it's like abandonment.
If you feel so inclined, you can pursue "abandonment" against the Doctor. Given the powerful meds you're on, I think you have an excellent case....Especially since he put you on these meds. I would think seriously about this possibility.
I found this physician reference on patient abandonment:
Patient Abandonment
A health care provider may decide or be forced to terminate services to a patient for any one of a variety of reasons. Although terminating services to a patient is certainly a significant and undesirable event, it is legally permissible if the provider carefully follows certain steps before discontinuing services. If the provider fails to follow these steps, it may find itself liable to the patient based on the theory "abandonment" if the patient alleges he or she suffered injury because the provider terminated services without sufficient notice.
This article will discuss the steps a health care provider should take to terminate services to a patient without committing patient abandonment.
A provider may want to quit providing services to a patient for many reasons, including:
The patient refuses to cooperate with the provider and its staff.
The patient will not pay his or her bills.
The patient is unruly and obnoxious to the point where it is in the best interests of all concerned for the provider to quit providing services.
Reimbursement for services has been denied or the provider has ceased to be a Medicare or Medicaid provider.
Environmental factors exist which endanger the provider's staff (e.g., physical threats, a dangerous dog, sexual harassment).
What a provider must not do, however, is "abandon" a patient. Abandonment generally means a unilateral severance of the professional relationship between a health care provider and a patient without reasonable notice at a time when there is still a need for continuing health care.
Court decisions involving patient abandonment generally deal with abandonment by physicians. Still, the legal principles established by those cases are instructive for other providers. For example, in interpreting Ohio law in 1965, the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio quoted an earlier Ohio decision which stated:
"....although a patient may, in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, discharge a physician at any time, before a physician or surgeon can withdraw from the case, it is necessary for him to give reasonable notice to the patient in order that another physician may be procured, the character of the services of the physician and his relation to the patient being such that he is not permitted under the law to arbitrarily quit the services at any time without any cause, and leave his patient without medical attendants."
Three elements must exist for patient abandonment to occur:
The termination of services must be unilateral, i.e., not by mutual agreement.
The termination must occur without reasonable notice, meaning notice adequate to give the patient a sufficient opportunity to secure alternative care; and,
The termination must occur when there is still the necessity of continuing care.
What to do
Because the issue of patient abandonment arises in a situation in which the health care provider, itself, desires to unilaterally terminate services at a time when there is a need for continuing care, the key to avoiding patient abandonment is to give reasonable notice of the termination of services. The underlying rationale is that reasonable notice affords the patient time to secure alternate care and the patient therefore is not "abandoned." If reasonable notice is given, that critical second element for patient abandonment does not exist.
Given this background, the following steps are generally expedient when a health care provider feels compelled to discontinue services to a patient:
(1) Examine the Patient's Records
First, the patient's records should be carefully examined to determine the degree of need, if any, for continuing care and the availability of other sources of care, i.e., other providers. If a patient is in the midst of ongoing care by the provider and is unable to find comparable care or has not been given adequate notice of the provider's intention to discontinue services, then the provider should not discontinue services without pursuing the remainder of these steps.
(2) Notify Attending Physician
Second, assuming the provider is not the patient's physician, the patient's attending physician should be notified in writing of the problems the provider is experiencing with the patient and that it is the provider's intention to stop providing services. The physician may be able to intervene to correct the problem or to assist the patient in finding another provider that will provide services comparable to those provided by the provider terminating services.
(3) Give Reasonable Notice to the Patient
Third, the patient, or those responsible for the patient's care, should be notified in writing as to the date the services will end, the reason or reasons for the action and the ways in which the provider will assist the patient in securing appropriate services elsewhere.
The letter should advise the patient that the provider will make available to the patient, and other providers retained by the patient, copies of all medical records and other information relating to the patient. This helps in maintaining continuity of care for the patient.
It also could be useful for the letter to give the names, addresses and telephone numbers of other providers in the area which would be available to provide services to the patient.
Generally, the letter should be sent by certified mail, return receipt requested, so the provider can prove the letter was received by the patient or the responsible party. A copy of the letter should be sent to the patient's physician as well. A copy of the letter and the return receipt should be kept in the patient's records.
This notice must be received by the patient far enough in advance of the date services will terminate to give the patient sufficient time to secure alternate care, i.e. it must be "reasonable". How far in advance will be held to be reasonable will depend upon the facts of each case including the patient's condition, the availability of other providers, the ramifications if alternate care is not secured, and the reason for termination of services.
Exact Steps Depend Upon the Situation
The foregoing steps are a basic approach concerning discontinuing services to a patient. Remember, however, the key step is the third one -- giving reasonable notice to the patient.
Because each situation can be unique, it can be very helpful for a provider to have a written policy stating the steps to be followed prior to unilaterally terminating services to a patient. By setting forth the steps to be followed and who within the provider makes the final decision as to whether or not services will be terminated, the policy can assist in avoiding inadvertent liability through patient abandonment.
It must be emphasized, however, that the appropriate resolution of a specific case depends upon the particular facts surrounding it. Before choosing a specific course of action, therefore, a provider should consult with its attorney to discuss the situation and to obtain advice based upon the specific facts involved.
________________________________________ ________________________
Again, I think you have a very good case. Not only do you have critical, continuing need for care, but you're on controlled meds....That this Doc put you on and, the most powerful med on the market. Finding someone to prescribe you 2400mcg of fentanyl per day isn't the easiest task in the world. Just to give you a general idea of how strong this is, a 100mcg patch, (2400mcg per day) is equivalent to 480mg of Oxycodone, or 720mg of Hydrocodone, or 180mg of Dilduad....All per day! Not to be crass, but 480mg of Oxycodone is (96) 5mg Percocets per day.
Thus, I think you've got an excellent argument about potential consquences and access to care. "Do not harm" is the oath he took....He needs to follow it.