Don't know if you've already had the problem fixed from Nov., but here's what happened to me when faced with the same choice. Even tho my dental insurance would've paid for a bridge and not the implant, I went with the $1500 implant. I couldn't justify grinding the 2 teeth on either side & crowning them for the bridge, plus you have to consider that you might lose those 2 teeth also, due to excess stress placed on them. The insurance ended up covering the extraction of the bad tooth, plus 50% of the 1 crown on the implant. As far as pain, putting in the implant was a piece of cake compared to the extraction. I only took Advil for the first day. The whole setup cost a lot of $, yes, but it looks & feels like a real tooth (and is easier to clean than a bridge). They say 10% of implants fail within 10 years, so I hope mine lasts. Good luck.