Ive had zero success with any of them and spent way too much money on them as well! Go see a dermatologist, for less than the price of one product, youll get answers. I had much the same thing going on, and it was "age' related. Mine started at age 38....its called adult acne and the cysts you are describing are key to it....the doc will put you on a low antibiotic to be taken mid cycle time, and believe me, its 100% more effective then any cleansing routine.
Good luck.