Anything I believe is possible. Everyone is different. Your doctor should have let you stay at 50mcgs if you still felt well. Though your TSH had gone up, you were still feeling good. He should have listened to you instead of the TSH. On the other hand, did he do fT3 and fT4? Antibodies? If not, you should try to get him to test these and see where they're at. It could be that these are out of whack and that's what's causing your symptoms. Generally speaking, TSH should normally be at the low end. fT3 and fT4 should be closer to the high end. Hope this helps.
"Troubles are often the tools by which God fashions us for better things".
Live, Love, Laugh.