Interesting question. Let me know if you ever find the answer.
I think this is one of those riddles to which the answer may never be figured out. I mean... each body is so different from the next, and so, each body's reaction to a med will be different.
I now take 1 1/2 grains of Armour, which on 'the chart' should be equivalent to 111-150 mcgs Synthroid; but that much Synthroid literally would've killed me. I couldn't take 50 mcgs of Synthroid without it sending my FTs over the top.
That's why I think that trying to compare one drug to another for effectiveness is an exercise in futility.
You mentioned in a previous post that you were successful on Thyrolar, that a previous MD cut the dose, and you've had trouble ever since. Have you tried going back on it yet? I know it isn't commonly prescribed... Is that the reason you aren't taking it now?