What's the "a water pill" ??
Yes, Have taken Phen. Does it help? YES. BUT! (you knew there was a "but" right?") ONLY if you do your part. It's not a take the pill eat what you want and become skinny overnight solutions! People thinkg that. Take it (ASK YOUR DOCTOR!!! PLEASE don't order it online. You WILL be surprised how receptive your OWN dr. might be).
It gives you an energy burst, curbs appetitie. Do either of those make you lose weight? NO! That's the point. It DOES point you in the right direction though! YOU have to do the rest. GOOD LUCK!