|
HealthBoards Bulletin Board
![]() Cerebral Palsy
![]() Surgery-Good or Bad?
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Surgery-Good or Bad? | Page views: |
|
Dannycee Newbie ![]() Posts: 2 |
I havent heard any positive stories from anyone who had surgery...does anyone have any or is it just temporary relief until another surgery??? All opinions please ![]() IP: Logged |
|
Thereandbackagain Newbie ![]() Posts: 1 |
I am not a doctor, but I had several CP surgeries as a child. I'm 32 years old. My CP wasn't terribly severe in the sense that I could walk with crutches and now walk unasited. Some argue that it helps with muscles that are hypertense and thus allowing for greater mobility. The drawback is that many of the surgeries like the adductor transfer (inner thigh) are a tradeoff. Mine stopped my knees from crossing, but now I walk with bent knees. I had heelcord surgeries, but even today I don't have a great deal of movement in my ankles. I'm not sure what I would have been like without them, but there might be other alternatives to try first if it is a less severe case. The traditional passive stretch is limited because it just stretches the muscles. They just go back if you don't keep doing it. I think a better investment might be in a really good massage therapist and a qualified Reiki practitioner. They are expensive, but a lot less expensive than surgery. For excercise Tai-Chi and meditative excercises are sometimes better than ordinary PT, which just focuses on forcing the muscles to do what they don't want. I think the key is to find something that calms the person rather than causing more discomfort (especially for a kid) and ultimately strengthenes the mind first and body second. CP is a brain disease. The tight muscles are just a symptom. IP: Logged |
|
lascot Senior Member ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 207 |
I've had a bunch of operations on my legs & feet. Most during childhood. Now close to years old. i have alot more pain stiffness and low energy. Yep, the operations due usually come in a series. They have not been a cure. They are a treatment. In my case, I think a worthy one. I know that w/o my operations i would not be able to stand or walk.... The one thing I wish I'd done: dancing. As a childhood thing or at home with video--for coordination & the stretching. Its never too late but i think i may have been more fearless as a lassie. LAS IP: Logged |
|
prisc1125 Senior Member ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 103 |
The surgeries for me were a necessity. I came to the surgery route later in life (31) than most CP folks I know. I only found out at 31 that I had CP so imagine my surprise! Long and short: I tore a ligament in my R foot after running a marathon and it took two years of various docs and PT to get to this dx and my current ortho. In that time, I did more damage compensating and the foot got quickly and progressively worse. I just had my fourth foot surgery in February for hardware removal and FDL re-release. On the whole, I'm very been pleased compared to where I was and have an ortho who has really gone to bat for me. I continue to have lots of tightness in the foot/calf and limited ROM in the ankle due to all the work. I have not been a textbook case at all through this. Lots of the things that are expected to work have not so it is all wait and see. In the meantime, I do what I can to stay active -- swimming, walking, Pilates, weights, biking. My case is mild, but, as I've learned, that is such a relative term. If it were so mild, I'd not be at the mercy of specialists. I am still glad I had the work done. While the recovery took alot of time away, I can walk better now. Expect to need tune-ups every now and again. IP: Logged |
|
Texacali213 Junior Member ![]() ![]() Posts: 6 |
Hi. I'm new here and read that you wanted some opinions on surgery. I am not a professional in this area, but have had most of the common muscle release surgeries when I was a child (I'm 35 now). What I have learned is that some of the procedures done to help certain conditions caused other conditions to arise. Do I think I shouldn't have had surgery? I don't know. They corrected things that made my life easier in some ways, but more difficult in others. I had my heel cords cut at 18 months. It left me with 40% muscle strength permanently lost. I now need to have them done again, but am not about to lose another 40%. So I live with tight heelcords. This would be fine if I hadn't had a triple fusion on my ankle joints when I was 10. So now the tight heelcords are cause tremendous stress on ankle joints that don't move. OUCH! I walk on forearm crutches and hold down two jobs-- I just have to deal with the pain. Don't get me wrong-- I try not to be bitter. I've talked to my Mom and she explained that the doctors told her that I had to have the surgeries in order to live a normal life. I understand that. But at what cost in the end? In my professional life I have worked with severely disabled children and listened to parents agonize over what the best treatment is. This is good for me because it gave me insight into the challenges Mom faced and the mindset the doctors were in. I don't the answers to your questions, but this was my experience. Texacali213 ------------------ IP: Logged |
|
BarbaraH Senior Member ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Posts: 149 |
Hi, My 19 year old son was born 3 months early and has spastic diplegia. He began therapy at 18 months but could not walk alone because of too much "tone". He got around well using a small Kaye posture walker. I carried him often. When he was 5 years old, he had his first surgical procedure, a selective dorsal rhizotomy, done in Louisville, KY at Kosair Children's Hospital in 1989. That procedure was followed by therapy 3x weekly and 11 months post-op, he was able to walk alone for the first time and to the cheers of his fellow 1st graders! He continued in therapy and at times has needed a cane for better balance. He has endured many falls over the years because of balence problems. At age 15 he needed bilateral hamstring releases and a left posterior tib. lengthening because his growth was causing him to have a crouched gait. 6 weeks of bilateral long leg casts followed and then more therapy. He walks without support and with sightly flexed knees. He also has build 4 computers and will enter college this fall intending to major in computer science and engineering. NOTE: The surgery he had at age 5 was the best thing for him. It was important for the success of that procedure that he had not had previous orthopedic surgery. I encourage you to explore all the options so you can decide what is best for you child with all the information in front of you. Good luck! IP: Logged |
All times are ET (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
|
home |
join free |
boards |
search |
about us | Copyright (c) 1998-2003 HealthBoards.com All rights reserved.
|
contact |
disclaimer |
board guidelines |
privacy |