Quote:
Originally Posted by Callista In any case, if no one were vaccinated, the diseases MMR protects against would kill more people than are autistic today--and autism doesn't kill anyone; measles, mumps, and rubella do. |
I've heard similar lines of reasoning, even from pediatricians ... but I don't buy it.
Some of the facts are in, and some are not in.
We do know, that before a measles vaccine was introduced, the USA had about 350 deaths, per yr., on average, attributed to measles. Mortality in rubella is less than in measles, and mortality in mumps is
rare.
So, worst case, MMR vaccine prevents about 500 deaths per yr., assuming no one has been vaccinated. But since the incidence of measles is very low at present (due to mass vaccination), the vaccine is now preventing a few deaths per yr. ... debatable, depending on how you frame it.
Rubella can cause significant handicaps; however, so does severe autism.
How many autistic people do we have in the USA today? Recent estimate is 1 in 150 people, using DSM-IV definition (does not include those with "tendencies.") The National Autism Association study suggested that currently we have approx
500,000 individuals with autism at present in the USA.
The
Journal of Insurance Medicine reported in 1998 that standardized mortality rates for autistic individuals exceeded that in the general population, with a mortality rate twice as high for males (197%), and nearly five times (470%) higher for females. Autistics suffer a higher incidence of accidental death, as well as a significantly higher incidence, approx. 10%, of deaths of unknown cause, even following autopsy. If we were to look at the numbers comparing children only, the indexed mortality comp. to normals is even more staggering.
So, even though autism doesn't kill quickly like say, untreated measles, there
is a significant mortality risk associated with autism. It's just that it's not as dramatic & therefore the association of death, with autism, is more easily ignored.
I hope that readers will consider facts when making decisions about vaccinations.
Best wishes.