i think you know my story by now, we seem to be connected with the timing
it took me almost a month for my foot to feel more comfortable breaking into my shoes where the brace was. on the back, the incision, and even underneath my foot felt weak in those areas as well as the skin being agitated easier. i had to wear thick socks and put tape on heel.
i felt like my range of motion was more as well without the brace like i was stretching things out more during real world activities. with that came what i call another breaking in period. for me it was hiking so i introduced myself slowly because my steps felt new and i was scared without the brace.
i had the same pattern where i would go like 5-6 days of doing my thing and then get aches/pains and back off and hit it again. i strung together a massive amount of hiking in a 2 month period and was feeling very positive at that point.
i started to get a side to side tightness that didn't seem to effect my normal movement. however i noticed if i tried to pivot or do an extreme angle step like on a rock. something i wouldn't think twice about with my good foot. whats wierd is it wasn't always like this, which is mimicing a wobble board.
so i continued on and a few weeks ago it started to become more annoying with pinching that does effect my stride and i limped one day which i haven't had to do in months. i have taken 2 , 5 day breaks recently and my foot is just now starting to settle down as far as what i percieve as the pinching pains. side to side is still tight.
so i would say its like learing to walk again and you have to be carefull. im still not totally connected to my foot

i started to wear my brace like you suggested and plan on getting active again this week.
i will also visit another doc but i have issues with the health insurance and needing a new doc, obamacare kicked me to medi-cal due to damages i suffered from injury.
if you had asked me weeks ago i would have said i still had issues but felt since i progressed thus far i just had more work to do. now im scared and paranoid about my foot and wished i kept the brace on even though im not aware of any trauma i suffered.
another thing is i quit with the rehab exercises when i started doing all this hiking and figured i would back off due to all the activity. i am now wondering if i messed up and should have continued massage and all the balance, stretching, theraband exercises religously.
i also wonder if weight training is a key to all this and getting everyting else real strong to keep things in place. i have noticed as i dabble in this recently that its totally different than cardio and hiking and it feels like i have been ran over. its going to be hard for me to go to the gym but i have to try, i think it may be a part of the puzzle.
just curious if you know in cases like ours, can a new doctor get a good idea of whats going on by manual manipulation to make sure things are atleast in place and solid? i just wanted to prepare myself for new docs i don't want to take any info with me and don't have it, i want another opinion. i figure surgery is out of the question for these things.