It appears you have not yet Signed Up with our community. To Sign Up for free, please click here....

Weight Loss Message Board

Is it really all about the name of a diet???

Post New Thread   Closed Thread
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 06-16-2005, 06:03 AM   #1
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Leominster, MA
Posts: 50
katied1183 HB User
Is it really all about the name of a diet???

Hi everyone!

I am new to this board, and i've been reading over a lot of posts and i find it really interesting to hear about so many different types of diets and fads and what people think about them. I want to make a comment/suggestion though based on my own experience.

All through high school and college I've generally been very conscious of my weight. At times I'd say at times, I felt unhappy and self conscious about my body and my weight, and other times it was more of just being aware and wanting to tone up a little and be more healthy. The problem is that after so many years of constantly thinking about food and weight, it became what I thought was just simply "normal" for me. My next meal was always my focus. during the down times my focus was okay how am i going to pick the food with the least amount of calories, and during the good times i was thinking, hey i dont care, i'll eat that brownie and the cake!. when i look back now i realize that my problem had much much more to do with the WAY in which i thought of food. what i picked to eat was a result of my psyche and my mood. As a result, i have to admit that what was "normal" for me was obsessive to everyone else. i cared so much about food and excercise that i was constantly visiting boards liem these, reading diet books, reading bilogy books, ANYTHING! the bad thing was that i was obsessed. the good thing is that NOW, i consider myself very educated on how the body processes food and just in general how different foods affect the body and weight.

that being said, i just want to raise a question to everyone. Have you ever noticed how much people attach stereotypes to the names of certain diets and how much clout people put on different diets solely because of what they claim instead of every taking the moment to figure out teh "WHY" behind the diet??? for example, take the atkins diet and south beach diets. people hear about these diets and all they think is LOW CARB. when i was following south beach, i had people sneering at me because they were like thats ridiculous, this low carb thing is such a fad. my point is -- i AGREE. the low carb thing IS a fad. but the aspect of south beach that isnt a fad is much more about eating healthily and choosing the types of foods that your body can process best without having spikes in glucose levels (which leans to more insulin being produced and in the long run being hungier more often and less able to burn extra calories -- this is a very BASIC BASIC description i know, look up more if you want). anyway, my point is that after all the research i did and after following southbeach i realized that the only reason teh diet "worked" for me was because of the WILLPOWER factor. I realized that in general, i felt like the fact that i was on a plan gave me a reason to keep going. HOWEVER, i think what too many people do is make teh mistake of thinking is the PLAN ITSELF that is causing the weight loss, as if its soem magic combination of the food and the eating schedule (on any diet, not just south beach) that cause the weight loos. but its NOT!!!!!!

what i think everyone needs to focus more on is WHY a particular diet might work and also realize that there is nothign special about it, even if it does work. i dont follow south beach anymore, but i do still keep in mind the principles behind the diet. i try not to eat sweets and cakes and stuff like that, and when i do eat bread and carb based products, i always choose the wheat or whole grain based kind. its all a matter of knowign whats healthy and how your body will react.

I just really hope everyone (as in our society) can start to realize tehre is no single diet that is better than any other, and I GUARANTEE that if you were to take 10 different types of diets that worked for people they would all have two things in commin -- they all contain healthy foods and the amount of calories the people ingest are around the recommended daily allowance. (all of these diets of course would have to be ones that promote eating natural foods and refrain from promoting their own diet foods/prducts like slim fast and atkins, which i personally believe are not maintainable for the long term)

Also, get up and excercise!!!!! our society has become so intent on finding quick fixes for everything, what with all the pill popping we do lately. yes, food is important to a diet, but NOTHIGN CAN REPLACE exercise!!!!! I know you all know this, but i think its good for everyone to hear it once in a while. sometimes i just really dont feel like going to the gym, but when i think abotu the fact that i've been sitting at my desk for 9 hours straight and ate 1800 calories, even if those calories were healthy ones, i wont lose weight if i dont do somethign to burn some of them off!

SO, in then end i just want to say congratulations to everyone who has found a diet plan that works for them and has had success doing it, but please try to focus on why and how that plan as worked for you and make sure this particular plan can work for you in the long term. your weight loss has nothing to do with the name of your plan or any magic foods or combination thereof that you have been eating. it is all about moderation, healthy foods, and exercise!!!!! and if you are buying those shakes and bars and popping pills, then i'd suggest you go to barnes and noble fast and buy a nutrition book.....belive me, it helps, AND isnt it cool to know how you're own body works????

okay i know this was long, but this is a topic that i've thought about a lot and i think its really important. thanks for reading!
"No one can make you feel inferior without you're consent." ~Eleanor Roosevelt

Sponsors Lightbulb
Old 06-16-2005, 07:12 AM   #2
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 52
Zootroy HB User
Re: Is it really all about the name of a diet???

You said low carb diets are a fad when they are not. Maybe the names to them are, but low carb is essential for weight loss since carbs, especially in pure sugar form, contain more calories than protein does per gram.

The bigger problem is people being lazy and not willing to try to lose weight. Some pills do work, but not without proper nutrition, some exercise AND commitment (the thing everybody forgets).

Old 06-16-2005, 07:24 AM   #3
Senior Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 631
LV40 HB User
Re: Is it really all about the name of a diet???

DIET is a four letter word.

Old 06-16-2005, 10:05 AM   #4
Junior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 47
jtb7 HB User
Re: Is it really all about the name of a diet???

What it really boils down to is you have to want the weight loss more than you want the brownie, you have to eat fewer calories, burn some calories and be determined. I find that the number one reason any one fails at any plan is that the just don't want it bad enough. I know I had to come to a place where I wanted it bad enough to not mind feeling a little hungry in the evening and drinking water instead of eating. There are different reasons for different people as to why they want the food more than the wt loss. For me just recently, it had to do with pain. I can';t make it go away, but I can make the hunger go away, and the depression that came with the pain was "comforted" by food. And then of course the pain meds. made me sick to my stomach and the only way to make it go away was to eat, carbs or something big, not an apple. I only say all of this to demonstrate the mental power that is needed. I can't speak for all plans, but I did ww and lost the 20 lbs i gained after my first accident. Basically, it took the guesswork out of how much food to eat. I learned alot about the value of food.

Old 06-16-2005, 11:45 AM   #5
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Leominster, MA
Posts: 50
katied1183 HB User
Re: Is it really all about the name of a diet???


yes, you're right, what i meant by calling low carb diets a "fad" were the names and all the processed products that go along with them. i reread my post and realized that i didnt go a very good job of explaining what i wanted to say. the point i wanted to make was that it is the general concepts behind the "diets" that work, not the specific diet and its products itself. you can follow south beach or atkins or any other low carb lifestyle without having to buy all those low carb products (whether generic products or specific to the program itself). if you understand the way your body works, then you can stick to natural foods and STILL be following the concepts. like i said, although i dont follow south beach anymore, i did very much like that it stressed eating whole and natural foods, not relying on bars and shakes etc. however, i understand that many people feel most motivated when they stick very closely to a particular program, and of that is what gets them motivated then more power to them! i have found for myself though, that i feel more empowered when i know that I am the one taking charge of what i eat and i control the foods i put in my body. that way, i dont feel guilty if i have one brownie. when i was on south beach, i felt guilty when i cheated cuz all i could picture was my glucose completely skyrocketing. now though i am still eating low carb and losing weight, but i am not in ketosis and i do eat a small amount of carb based products every day, but all are whole grain, and all have a low glycemic index. when i eat a sweet from time to time i dont feel guilty, but i do feel very thankful to have learned a lot about how my body works and processes food from reading the south beach book.

sorry that i didnt orginally do a great job of explaining, i will take more care to do so in future posts. great job to everyone who has found a plan that works for them. stay motivated!!!!
"No one can make you feel inferior without you're consent." ~Eleanor Roosevelt

Closed Thread

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Board Replies Last Post
In desperate need of help. Just stopped my diet. asjdwf021 Weight Loss 8 06-21-2010 07:01 PM
I really need some help/direction please! campark Autism Spectrum 12 04-23-2008 04:25 PM
Question about blood during a bowel movement squall211 Bowel Disorders 2 01-16-2008 01:11 PM
Grumbling rectum, what is wrong with me?It is really starting to affect my sociallife health_freak Bowel Disorders 111 03-22-2006 07:31 PM
Can yeast really cause CFIDS/Fibro Bothrops Chronic Fatigue 20 06-14-2005 10:05 AM
which diet pills do really work? computris2 Weight Loss 11 08-26-2004 06:31 PM
Just about all the posts talking about pills... jowi Weight Loss 1 12-12-2003 08:45 AM
What is the name of the Atkins book? ~Melody~ Obesity 4 11-25-2003 10:52 AM

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Sign Up Today!

Ask our community of thousands of members your health questions, and learn from others experiences. Join the conversation!

I want my free account

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:51 AM.

Site owned and operated by HealthBoards.comô
© 1998-2018 HealthBoards.comô All rights reserved.
Do not copy or redistribute in any form!