I like Tylenol Vanilla PM. Works great for me, not drowsy the next day and only take it when needed.
Quote from Mittens_Kittens:The cheapest, most effective thing I've found is generic Benedryl (Wal-Mart brand is what I use). Tylenol PM is actually just a combination of Tylenol and Benedryl. So if you don't need a pain reliever, you're overmedicating by taking both.